Posting your rating...

SaidWhatWhen

Authority | Member since 2016 | United States

9 Ratings | 3 Likes

Brand

Review

Rating

Ron Del Barrilito 3 Star

World Class Truly the Star of Puerto Rican rum and at less than $25 btl on the island, its the value champ of all rum. This is a fairly dry rum with a wide palate

Santa Teresa 1796

Marvelous sipper Raisins, oak, spice and depth of age all describe this drink. No one flavor dominates so each time you can find something new. Beautiful dark amber co

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Tropical Beach Fantasy Classic rum flavors with lots of coconut and just enough banana, cocoa and vanilla; not too sweet. Very approachable starting point for wooing your fr

Mount Gay XO Extra Old

The Great All-Rounder Mount Gay XO screams excellence. Great balance of spice flavors, sweetness, oak. This rum has it all. Almost impossible to pin a style to it, other

A better Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva without the Venezuelan baggage Very similar in taste to the above, but a bit richer. Not sure how the Venezuelans are still producing anything aged as the economy is in ruins, so I

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Great sweet rum, but not enough depth of flavors. Wonderful, sweet rum with a heavy body. Flavor palate is not that wide. Needs more than its monolithic flavor to become "great".

Kirk and Sweeney

Pulls no punches This rum just doesn't work for me. On the nose, there is a good bit of vanilla, oak, and a touch of honey. On the tongue however, it is a different

Smells like Roundup I was really looking forward to this as I am partial to drier rums. Very disappointed by the harsh, weed killer scents and flavors of this rum. On t

Pyrat XO Reserve

Orange Monster More like bad orange liqueur than rum. One note wonder in a pretty bottle.

Wishlist

Brand

Type

Country

Average Rating

Total Ratings

RumRanking:

Authority

SaidWhatWhen rated Mount Gay XO Extra Old over 2 years ago
SaidWhatWhen rated El Dorado 12-Year over 2 years ago
SaidWhatWhen rated Plantation XO 20th Anniversary over 2 years ago
SaidWhatWhen rated Clement VSOP over 2 years ago
SaidWhatWhen rated Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva over 2 years ago