Go Premium: no ads, rum prices, unlock Flair, +more
Posting your rating...
Aficionado | United States
Flor de Cana
That's the stuff
Good. Really good. Wood, vanilla, leather, dark chocolate. Fantastic.
Port Cask Finish
Close to perfection. Great flavors, mouthfeel, and finish.
Zinfandel Cask Blend
Richard can do no wrong
He is King Midas, in my opinion. I will buy anything he makes and almost certainly love it. Whoever said walnuts at the end nailed it.
Aniversario Reserva Exclusiva
Tobacco. Not overly sweet. This is fantastic tasting.
Better than the 15
especially in an old fashioned. This is good. They story is great. Wooden stills are the greatest. This could be better but it’s towards the top of my
Everything this man touches is gold
This is, without a doubt, the best bang for buck you can buy... if you can find it. It’s fantastic. No colorings or added sugars, just generations of
Wanted it to be better
Really like their other stuff but expected their most premium blend to taste more, well, premium. Not bad, mostly oak and Tobacco, just a bit of poor
Cuba Libre El Dorado
Won this from #whiskysanta
It's great. Exceptional. Almost too rich and savory so I can't drink too much of it. A little nutty.
Won this from #whiskysanta
It's great. Exceptional. Almost too rich and savory. A little nutty.
Like it but not enough for the price
Don't get me wrong, it's a really good rum. But I'm not sure if it is worth the RRP. That being said, I would never turn it down when offered.
Just a sip
Got a little taste at the local tiki rum bar. Really delicious. Will need to come back for more.
Great for spiced
Not worth an 8 but gets a bump because I generally avoid spiced rums. This one, though, is really good neat and as a mixer.
Brought back from Belieze for me. Very good. Smooth, brown sugar, hint of vanilla.
That’s good stuff
Didn’t expect the five year to be this good but I really like it
Nutty. A little tabaco-y. Very delicious. I like this a lot.
Better than most
But not my favorite foursquare. Still, a master class in distilling.
Tesoro Single Malt Whisky Finish
Nice taste up front with no burn and just a little more sweetness than I want. Great finish.
The rum that got me into rum
I have a soft spot for this one even though it is very much on the sweet side. I like it and my wife loves it.
Kirk and Sweeney
Got this one as a gift from friends - smells of raisins, has a savory oaky taste. I'm not getting as much vanilla as some of the others on here but it
Always loved the uniqueness
Such a fun flavor - apple pie with a bit of orange. Very unique and heavy on the cinnamon. Smells of brown sugar, as well. Great little rum from someo
Hard not to like
Despite my best efforts, it's good and a nice one to recommend for people who haven't ventured into rum. Like others, I'm less than enthused both
Agree that it's good but too expensive
Fantastic aromas, very smooth, but nothing spectacular, especially for $60-$70 a bottle. There is a strange taste in there as soon as you swallow, it
Oaky. Dry. Easy to drink. Opens up more as it sits.
Good for the price
Slightly sweet, especially coming out of Barbados, but that's the fun with the cognac process that makes Plantation. Decent for sipping, especially on
Selección de Maestros
Had it in Havana - it's getting a bump in ratings for experience because the rum itself isn't that memorable and definitely not worth the price outsid
Plenty of vanilla. Smells sweeter than it tastes. I like
Great depth. Not as sweet as I was expecting. Would be great in an old fashioned.
Kirk and Sweeney
This is good
Especially for an agricole. It smells like caramel and pecans. It looks good in the glass. It goes down easy. But it tastes like added sugar. Maybe th
Try it once.
Glad I tried it. Probably wouldn’t drink it again.
Old Man Guavaberry
Way better than I was expecting
Pretty good. Sweet, a little astringent, would drink again.
I like it
It's not overwhelmingly sweet. I see what others are talking about with the ethanol taste but it is not overwhelming, either. It has a unique aftertas
Good in cocktails
Better than Bacardi and should hold some sort of soft spot for many rum drinkers. Would crush Bacardi if (when?) allowed in the US.
Let it breath
Gets better when it sits for a while. Still, not fantastic.
The Forgotten Cask
Expected a bit more. Not sure what I didn't like about it but wouldn't order again.
Similar rating to Forgotten Casks
Lower mostly because I expected more. Love their spiced, really wanted to love their others, especially the more premium ones.
1919 Deluxe Aged Blend
Not too sweet
Which is nice. But it has a flavor at the end I just don't like.
Good little local rum
Not fantastic but pretty good. Aged in Laws Whiskey barrels, so that's fun.
Tastes better than it smells
The nose says ethanol and fusel oil but the taste is much tamer. Visually it is super light and doesn’t appear to have spent a lot of time in the barr
The Duppy Share
Tried it at RumFest the past couple of years - I must have been a bit deep both times because it's not nearly as good as I remember. Smells fruity
Gold of Mauritius
Fun flavor but almost medicinal
Loved the taste of hazelnuts at rumfest last year but regretted it the next day when I opened it and the flavor seemed a bit off. Fun to put in a
Eh, it's fine
Not fantastic but better than entry level. Would drink in a bind, as the rating says.
Not for me. Enjoy the story. Not the spiced. Woof.
Packed full of flavor
But not all of it is good. Smells sweet, tastes like vanilla and bananas, might be good mixed
Drinkable. Good in a pinch. Wouldn't order it if something else was available.
Glimmer of hope
I think the “4” rating fits this perfectly - flawed with a glimmer of hope.
Hard to take down the single I had... was trying to give it away. Not good.
RhumsTeq nailed it with the description of "syrupy." Taste like cough syrup or a really bad sugary fake fruit drink from childhood. Maybe even an unfr
Three Roll Brazilian Style
5 days ago
Captain Morgan 1671
6 days ago
Punta Cana Tesoro Single Malt Whisky Finish
11 months ago
Foursquare Port Cask Finish 9-Year
about 1 year ago
Foursquare Dominus 10-Year
about 1 year ago
See more rum ratings