Posting your rating...

Nicoakr

Superstar | Member since 2015 | France

106 Ratings | 88 Likes | 4 Followers

Brand

Review

Rating

Longueteau 2004 Grande Reserve 10-year

One of a kind Pure pleasure. Fruity with a floral and woody finish that never ends

Abuelo Centuria

Fantastic Great balance. Café, vanilla and eventually chocolate! A long beautiful finish. It has everything. I don't even know why I'm not giving a 10. I guess

Plantation 1997 Single Cask Trinidad

Unique Nose is rather flat. What happens next is so unique. Candy earthy smoky flavors with endless liquorice note on the finish. Delicious.

Ron Panama 21-year

Subtle Caramel, coffee, citrus, greens. Slightly leathery in the nose. Smooth mouth with caramel, coffee again. Complex. Orange zest. Lingering finish, wa

Ron Panama 12-year

Magnifique Beautiful mineral finish, very suble. Gets better over time.

Kirk and Sweeney 18-year

Splendid Almost got the perfect balance of strength and sweetness .

La Hechicera Extra Anejo

One of my favorites Very easy to drink. Fried banana aromas in the nose, sweet entry with a more smoky mineral finish.

Origenes Don Pancho Reserva Especial 18-year

Roundness An authentic carribean rum with sweetness and strength. Beautifully round. Just missing a liitle touch of madness to be perfect

Dictador XO Perpetual

Worth a sip or 10 Mineral nose with walnut and light caramel aromas. Very similar in the mouth which makes out for a great original sipper. Notes of coffee, walnut, sli

Plantation 2003 Nicaragua

Dates A favourite mixing flavors of passion fruits and dates into a round rum that finish beautifully.

Caroni Trinidad 17-year

With a kick A powerful yet subtle solution to your overproof needs. Very beautiful sharpness that elevates your senses with power.

Angostura 1824 12-year

Well done!! Beautiful as a digestive. Slightly spicy (anis, wood skin). Smooth lingering finish with vegetal notes.

El Dorado Special Reserve 15-year

Well done!! Lightly spiced nose. Fruity at first then bending towards an exotic cognac. Great balance, nice finish.

Santa Teresa 1796

Balance I liked it from the first sip. Very balanced rum. Great nose. Smoothness. The finish is a bit short maybe with a spice, maybe clove.

Ron Panama 8-year

Not quite then amazing Perfumed first nose, intense. Creamy caramel, peach then mineral. Green fruits, smoky cheap wood. Discreet later. Creamy caramel mouth, grilled bread

Compagnie des Indes 2000 Jamaica Hampden 14-year

Ripe banana skin The nose is insanely aromatic with overly ripe banana. It has a slightly fermented smell, in a good way. In the mouth the rum literally explodes, note

Trois Rivieres Cuvee de l'Ocean

The special one Very unique batch. Cuvée de l'ocean brings you mineral flavor, iodin, dryness and subtil flower notes.

Barbancourt 5 Star Reserve Especiale 8-year

Very fair quality product This is a very good starting point in the carribean rum enlarged family. Barbancourt 8 is smooth, easy to drink, with very tipical notes from its 8 ye

Clement Canne Bleue

Great rum Floral nose, round and balanced. Cant go wrong with that affordable rum.

El Dorado 12-year

Black pepper Fruity sweet nose. Black pepper, vanilla. A bit on the sweet side. Great value for $

Medellin 10-year

Pommes au four We bought this one purely for the esthetic of the bottle next to the Medellin 12. And this was the best decision we took over that weekend. It is in f

Flor de Caña 18-year

Strong vapor of ether Aromatic nose with l vapor of alcohol. Mouth is smooth. Tail is progressively strong and flavourful.

Malecon 12-year

Nice surprise Beautiful nose and balanced taste. Nice smell of orange and dried herbs. Mineral in mouth, even slightly sour which shows that the fermentation was we

Fair Gold 5-year

More than fair Interesting product as it is garanteed without added sugar or sweeteners. More on the mineral side with tropical fruits in mouth and wood towards the

Saint James 2001

Complex but strong Very floral nose, pear, Caledonian sousbois. Aggressive in mouth, clear dry wood, bitterness of grapefruit. Beautiful bouquet final that lasts with ca

Plantation Gran Anejo Guatemala

Candied fruits and cognac Beautiful nose with candied fruits and café. The mouth is smooth cognac and finding again soft tones of candied fruits. Nice one.

Isautier Rhum Arrangé Café Vanille

Nice enough Same as for the banana one, it's tricky to rate a commercial rum arrangé. This one performs well though the vanila tastes a bit artificial.

Nice discovery Finally a spicy rum that is not overly flavoured. Blended rum aged in Frnce in cognac barrels. Nicely done.

Millonario Reserva Especial 15

Sweet Nose candied apricots, dry fruits, mouth like a zacapa, rond très sucré, burned wood, long perfect finish

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Yaarrrrr Roundess at its best. Excellent mix of vintage Diplomatico. Very sweet feeling that makes it too easy to drink...

Abuelo Gran Reserva 12-year

Floral honey Miel fruity nose, hay. Leathery mouth with miel, banana, oak.

Ron Zacapa Centenario 15

A reference under $40 Great nose, smooth in mouth. Caramel, vanilla, light café that make for very nice, easy to drink and affordable drink. Lack a bit of ending in my opin

Flor de Caña 25-year

Noisette End of bottle. Toasty nose with a hint of hazelnut. Grilled flavours in mouth and long smooth finish, more buttery, balanced. Not a favorite but a goo

Dos Maderas PX 5+5

Nice originality Very dark in color. Agressive nose at first that then evolves very nicely. The Jerez is very present with aromas of cherry wood, toffee, fig and candi

Delicious Great surprise. I tried this rum in Barcelona with initial scepticism but was happily surprise to find this very well made white rum. So good that it

Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal

Interesting enough for a whity Interesting as a white rum, but it's not a true white rum in reality. Easy to sip. Tastes flowery but lack length. Very short.

Rum Nation Panama 18-year

Sweet toffee A bit too sweet. A nice hint of exotic fruits but unfortunately the sweetness takes everything..

Plantation 2005 Guyana

Lacks something Powerful in the nose with sweet notes. Rpund in mouth but somehow too typical with a feeling of deja bu!

La Favorite Coeur 4-year

Dried grass - Hay Very vegetal rum. Not for everyone but I enjoyed the originality of its flavors. I feel this is a very natural product without any additives.

Plantation Trinidad Original Dark Overproof

Interesting overproof Its an overproof with its share of ethanol smell initially. Though it opens up to beautiful toasted flavors, citric zests, wood skin. A killer!

Ron de Jeremy The Adult

Has to seat in the glass for a while Dry, too dry with powerful ethanol smell and flavors. After 30 min it becomes drinkable. Mineral rum with soft tones of stones. I lile mineral rums bu

Plantation 2004 Panama

Rum grand marnier Nose is very sweet and caramel. Mouth has all aspects of orange, from zest to orange licors.. a decent pick but not a favourite

Ron de Jeremy XO 15-year

Not my thing An intense rum that tries to surprise you but loaded too much on the sugarcane

Plantation Barbados Grande Reserve

A good sip Sweet round nose, very social at first. Round mouth too but tastes a little bit too modified

Sailor Jerry Spiced

Vanilla Extremely strong & sweet vanilla aromas, vanilla again in mouth with leathery warm finish, tobacco there too. In the end I was nicely surprised by th

Kraken Black Spiced

Carambar Not a joke this Kraken, it is a nice result if you're into this kind of spiced rums. Very rough nose at first but then opens up nicely with strong Car

Barcelo Imperial

Too serious Good rum but nothing special. Very easy to drink, quite oaky but it doesn't give you much else to sparkle the mind...

Abuelo Reserva Superior 7-year

Great everyday rum Not a great nose but I love the mouth. Nose Israel syrupy with aromas of woods. Mouth is smooth with a very good blend of spicies. Very aromatic, with

Havana Club 7-year

Smooth revolutionary A reference in roundness. Very well balanced, easy to drink. Lacks some power and spicyness maybe. A classic for my mojitos or Cuba libre.

Botran Solera 1893 18-year

Powerful but a bit disappointing It's a very good rum, not too sweet like many rums of the region. Nose I got lot of caramel and dry fruits. Mouth is more mineral which I like but I t

Mount Gay Eclipse

Not exquisite but good Basic rum with a good balance of spices. Nose is a bit aggressive initially then get towards chocolate and vanilla aromas. Mouth is balanced, slightly

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera

May be a problem with that bottle floral with strong aromas de ginebra, liquorice. Spicy mouth with something I don't like at first then caramel, sweetness. Strong alcohol at the end b

Plantation Isle Fiji

A bit young maybe Nice drink overall but it's missing a sparkle. Vegetal/onion nose, a bit woody. Then it's a bit flat. Some grilled coconut...

Havana Club Pacto Navio

Interesting Agressive nose. Mineral and herbal mouth. Very interesting product. Well made

Sister Isles Wine Barrel Reserva

Synthetic It's not a bad rum but it tastes artificial. Considering the aging, it should be rounder but it bites a bit...

Angostura 1919 8-year

Too easy a sip to be natural On the sweet side, rainforest on the nose and in mouth green banana and honey. Scrappy finish

Clement Blanc 40

Ti Punch Souvenirs souvenirs sipping ti punchs until mornings. With the right note of sugar it is a killer, right balance of force, fruits and spices. Better a

Matusalem Clasico 10-year

Drinkable It's drinkable. Not really interesting as a sipper.

Canaveral Extra Anejo

Smooth but.. Discretly sweet first nose, caramel coming out progressively, dusty corner smell, old cave. A bit of vanilla. Coffee, earthy, tobacco mouth. Smooth bu

Dictador 12-year

Coffee If I want coffee, I'll order coffee. Original rum but too much coffee and toffee.

Isautier Arrange Banane Flambie

A bit too much banana Haribo Rating a rum arrangé is tricky because it's rarily good at commercial level while it can be amazing at the little corner shack. This one is probably

Kind of good, kind of pricy Smooth nose with fair amount of vanilla. Opens up after at least 20min. Round mouth, a bit sweet with candied fruits and hints of bourbon. Pricy I fin

Havana Club Anejo Especial

Cuba Libre Not a favorite on ice or straight but the perfect rum for Cuba Libre.

Reference for caipirinhas Always a success in caipi however I wouldn't get close to that straight. Intense fruity and flowery nose, quite amazing. Very aggressive in mouth at f

Good Very classic Caribbean rum with the usual flavours

Tanduay Superior 12-year

Fair A very competitive mixer with Coke. Slightly spicy, smooth. But 12yrs old? Flavored 12 yes old? Can't really feel it's natural...

When in the Philippines Can't say it's great but it is a nice easy to drink rum with tones of oak and vanilla. A bit weak maybe but for $5 what can I say.

Good enough to avoid mixing it Great entry level rum. I prefer it on ice, lemon and mint with loads of ice but can easily be appreciated straight.

Botran Anejo 8-year

Peppery Decent rum. Vanilla, more mineral and spicy than sweet. Still gotta try the 18 and 25...

Medellin Gran Reserva 12-year

Better go for the 10yrs 95th anniversary edition Not bad but... Nice fruity first nose, more oaky afterwards. The mouth is a bit disappointing though it has a long warm finish. Vanilla and baked appl

Dillon Blanc 50

Le rhum agricole Fruity agricol rum. A reference for a good planteur. Harsh after taste if injected pure

Trois Rivieres Blanc 50

Floral and harsh An iconic drink that can't let you unmoved. Very floral in the nose but with lot of alcohol. Strong again in mouth. Burn in the tail but with nice aft

Santa Teresa Gran Reserva Linaje

Rough venez Smooth sweet first nose then more mineral. Strong in mouth, burnt caramel. After taste not too good.

Havana Club 3-year

Classic Young rum that already has character. Great mixer for Coke or mojitos

La Mauny Blanc 50

Gimme fruits Classic flavours from Martinique. A classic fruity scent that comes with its lot of agressivity. Powerful in mouth. Compare well to Dillon. Perfect to

Plantation Barbados 5-year

Not gonna leave a mark A classical slightly aged rum with the cognac cask finish rounding the angles. Nice sip but lacks complexity so quickly boring.

Union 55 Salted & Spiced

Not my slice of gouda Overly sweet and spiced rum that would disgust the toughest palates. Thank you but no thank you.

William Hinton 3-year

Vanilla syrup Vanilla in the nose, vanilla in the mouth and vanilla after-taste. Too sweet and full of vanilla flavour to be natural. Having said that Im a vanill

Diplomatico Añejo

Too much caramel Not a bad rum. Nose is full of caramel, too much for me. Fruity too though, with some mandarin and green banana. Mouth is fairly smooth, with flavours

Appleton Estate Reserve

A basic taste of Jamaica Good nose for a mild spicy rum. Not bad in mouth, a bit too peppery for me. Some good notes of honey and cinnamon. Hot smoky ending.

Don Papa Small Batch

Way too syrupy A very nice present to a non rum-drinker... It looks like a good rum. But as soon as you lower your nose into the glass you wonder what it is and how

Medellin 3-year

Rum in Tetrapak Well well, curiosity... Cheap party rum, can't expect so much!

Medellin 8-year

Rum for cola Not inspiring me enough to write anything. It says "rum" on the bottle!

Rond Nose plum, pruneaux. Smooth mouth. Flat finish. Good surprise. Conditions: partying

To burn stuffs maybe Horrible rum, not advisable for any human. Do not drink

Matusalem 7-year

Maybe a bad bottle Had a very untasteful experience with this one. Not my thing.

Coconut licor Cocococonut well don't know why I'm even rating this one

Appleton Estate White

Oily Basic white rum. Bought it to infuse and left a dose to taste. Smell is very neutral, can let me think it's a rum issued from clean molasses. In mouth

Pyrat XO Reserve

Synthetic orange Not of my liking. For me it is just an awful spicy orange rum. Not very well balanced.

Captain Morgan Dark

Not a favorite Very spicy and strong after taste of not-so-good rum

Very dry I don't know the history behind the production of Rum Duran and got to try it in an event without any expectations. Nose is dry without any particul

Ron Viejo de Caldas 3-year

Banana Strong aroma and taste of candied bananas, kind of easy to drink (I assume it has a lot of added sugar). Disgusting!

Red as a warning The classic rum of the Phikippines. Found almost anywhere for less than $2 a bottle. Can't expect much at this rate. It is drinkable with cola.

Agressive Definitely not my favorite cachaca. Quite aromatic in the nose but way too aggressive in mouth.

Saint James Royal Ambre 18-Mois

Even doubtful in a planteur The taste of Martinique but not quite the standing

Syrup Syrup de caramel with strong smell of ethanol. Dull!!

So so is an understatement Overly sweet and artificially enhanced. Never ever again

Tanduay Philippine

Wrong like its color One of the national drinks in the Philippines (yes one is not enough). A good drink to forget how shitty is Manila and see the bright side of things.

SangSom Special

Rum? I had a very good time with a few bottles of that liquid but can't call that rum. I'd like to learn more about how it's made. More of a caramelly whis

Negrita Bardinet Signature Dark 2-year

Great for cooking, not drinkable Very familiar rum since I was a kid. Used for baking and some other French and West Indies' dessert recipes

Good to desinfect a wound maybe Horrible stuff, from beginning to end. Nothing to get out of it. I would use it as a chemical cleaner, for nothing else and certainly not for drinking

Naughty Horrible liquid! Not even good enough to infuse with some spicies. Lasting naughty after-taste...

El Ron Prohibido Habanero 12-year

Walnut port wine Fruity first nose which turn into a walnut smell after 10min. Warm in mouth, nice on the tip of the tongue. Bend towards a sweet port wine, not a very

Wishlist

Brand

Type

Country

Average Rating

Total Ratings

Velier Royal Navy Very Old

Rum SixtySix Family Reserve 12-year

Heritiers Madkaud Vieux Cuvée Renaissance

Cuba Libre El Dorado 15-year

RL Seale 10-year

Cana Brava 7-year

Malecon Reserva Imperial 25-year

Plantation Panama Single Cask Pineau des Charentes Finish 8-year

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Debonaire 21-year

Origenes Don Pancho Reserva 30-year

Mezan 1999 Panama

Compagnie des Indes 2004 Panama Secrete 11-year

Compagnie des Indes 2004 Fiji South Pacific 10-year

Centenario 25-year

Quorhum 12-year

Dominican Republic

Blue Chair Bay Coconut

Panamonte Reserva XXV

Penny Blue VSOP