Go Premium: no ads, rum prices, unlock Flair, +more
Posting your rating...
Captain | United States
FOR THE PRICE-PERFECTION
So so smooth. Pure joy sipping with a close friend who appreciates not just fine rum but truly exceptional rum. Everyone is entitled to their own opin
Kirk and Sweeney
Incredible Nose: Perfect for Sipping.
When I had my first sip I thought I had peeled a banana! The banana fragrance hit me immediately followed by caramel and vanilla. A bit of coffee come
Reserve du Domaine 15-Year
A very nice sipping rum.
I would only drink it on ice.....several cubes..to cut into the initial strong alcohol flavor. The aroma of wood definitely comes through. A nice sipp
XO Extra Old
Slightly Better Than The Mount Gay Black Barrel
This is just a touch smoother than the Mount Gay Black Barrel. It's also heavier ( fuller ) taste wise. I gave the Black Barrel a 7. This one gets an
Very Good But Not Even Close To El Dorado 21
For the price this rum just doesn't "carry it's weight" to justify a rating over 8. If I were a professor I'd give the Appleton 21 a B+. It's certainl
Mixes well with OJ and tonic
Has a slight orangey taste....which I personally like as I like oranges. This is a light rum and can be addictive. Is it a top flight rum? No..but it'
Special Reserve 15-Year
Excellent But It's Not the 21!!!!
I know a lot of reviewers like sipping this on the rocks but after having..and keeping the 21 year old El Dorado...I've gotta mix this with a dash of
Great with lime and tonic
This isn’t a premium sipping rum but is certainly a premium mixing rum. Definitely prefer it over the Mount Gay black barrel. Not harsh at all. Will b
Smith and Cross
WOW!! This rum will wake up the dead!!
This rum is not to be played with...and for god’s sake don’t drive after drinking this amazing rum!! It’s not jet fuel but don’t light a match near i
Excellent on the rocks with a tiny tiny splash of tonic..with no lime/lemon. Smooth and most enjoyable. HOWEVER, if U look at the age and price of thi
A great mixing rum.....especially with OJ.
Three top tier restaurants stock the Black Barrel for me as I drink it with fresh squeezed orange juice. It's one of my favorite drinks. I wouldn't dr
Perhaps The Worst Rum I've Ever Had
Just plainly gosh awful. A server talked me into this and It was an effort to drink even half of it. ( I did because I was a guest at dinner). After d
5 months ago
Smith and Cross Navy Strength
10 months ago
Ron Zacapa 23 Solera
10 months ago
Kirk and Sweeney 23-Year
over 2 years ago
Sailor Jerry Spiced
almost 3 years ago
See more rum ratings