Posting your rating...

AndReginald

Aficionado | Member since 2018 | Italy

49 Ratings | 5 Likes

Brand

Review

Rating

Mount Gay 1703 Master Select

Very complex rum for special occasions Did a Masterclass with Mount Gay ambassador, Mr Chester Browne, who was really fabulous and a great man. Had this one as the last one in the tasting,

Plantation Xaymaca Special Dry

Hardest rating of all time This was my hardest rating so far. It is difficult to go beyond the impressions I had with previous Plantation experiences. I would like to ask to any

RL Seale 10-year

You'll never be the same I'm glad I bought this one on a very special occasion to celebrate. This is the rum I was looking for. Export proof 46 abv, you expect it to burn you

Doorly's 12-year

This set my bar higher This is what a rum should be. The aroma in the snifter is surprisingly sweet, knowing that there is zero added sugar. The rum is really smooth with an

Habitation Velier 2010 Hampden LROK 6-year

Very strong but you just have to wait 67% is really strong, especially on the nose. My personal advice is to let it rest a bit, then go at it slowly, giving your mouth some time. Strong mo

Mount Gay XO Extra Old

Great taste and smell, reminds of Christmas cake Did a Masterclass with Mount Gay ambassador, Mr Chester Browne, who was really fabulous and a great man. Had this one in the tasting, which was really

Foursquare 2004 11-year

Foursquare does it right This set a new bar for me today, I just think that everyone should taste this one and than rethink every previous rating of Barbadian rums. Dried frui

Samaroli 1999 Trinidad

You could drink the whole bottle This is one of a kind. I was lucky to taste this in a restaurant and the sommelier recognized me as an enthusiast so he poured it generously in a big

Mount Gay Black Barrel

Great on the nose, not so great in the mouth Edit: Did a Masterclass with Mount Gay ambassador, Mr Chester Browne, who was really fabulous and a great man. Had this one in the tasting but I think

Moon Import Jamaica "I Pappagalli" 11-year

Peculiar, long tobacco ending This is a special edition, very strong (45 °), it needs some time in the glass to rest. No sugar at all like all Jamaican rum. Big kick in the mouth o

Hampden Estate Pure Single Jamaican Overproof

Strong Jamaican rum This rum is very strong. If you can't enjoy overproof rum you should not taste this one and go for the 46% instead. Fruity rum, no sugar at all as all

Appleton Estate Rare Blend 12-year

You just want to drink another one This was a surprise for me, it's very dark and mysterious as others has said. Strong taste in your mouth at the first sip, it just need a bit to fully

Habitation Velier 2007 Last Ward 10-year

Strong but very good This is very strong (59) so if you are not into strong rum you should avoid this one. Otherwise a true Barbadian rum, lot of exotic fruit, almonds, va

El Dorado Special Reserve 15-year

Fruity and a great smell Tried this today and well it is very different from the 12 year. First of all I found it less sweet, although the test results says they have almost t

Hampden Estate 8-year

Let it rest 1 hour in the glass To all reviewers that gave this rum less than a 6, please give it a try and let it rest in your glass. If you do drink it right after you have poured

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Sweet and...just good If it wasn't so sweet I would have rate it a 9. Pleasant rum, no burn, fruity, very good in summer, I understand why most people like this. A bit pric

Doorly's 8-year

Dry bajan rum First of all this is a best valute for the price, finally in the Italian market for 27.5€, so you must buy this bottle asap because at that price you

Flor de Caña 12-year

A good everyday rum with no high expectations I call this the summer rum, because if it is very hot and you don't want to sweat on an ovenproof Jamaican rum but still stay away enough from the sug

J. Bally 12-year

First Agricole I would drink again It would be a 6 but I'm so impressed that I think it deserves a 7, because I'm always so severe with Agricole that this one may have changed my mind.

Moon Import Barbados Remember

Fine Barbados Rum Fine Barbados rum, with typical bananas, cocoa and a great finish. Worth a try if you have the chance.

El Dorado 2002 Versailles

Sweet and aromatic My only problem with this rum is that it's too sweet for me, I would give it a solid 8 but that sugar was too much. Nice vanilla and caramel taste, sw

Moon Import Guyana "Remember"

Nice Guyana rum Very nice sipper, a lot of vanilla but not too much sugar, definitely worth a try!

Foursquare 2008 Premise 10-year

Dry and Sherry Very dry rum, not sweet at all, spicy at a first taste, after two or three sip you can definitely taste the sherry. Maybe too much sherry for my taste

Rum Nation Trinidad 5-year

7.5, nice one, maybe some more years in the barrel This is a surprisingly nice rum for only 5 years in the barrel. That is why I gave it a 7.5 in the title. His weaknesses is that on the nose is almost

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Smooth rum This rum is really smooth and has a wonderful taste. It will leave you very satisfied and with the desire to drink another one! Sweet spectre. 8 if yo

Rhum JM VSOP 4-year

Nice but.. Very nice for an Agricole, but nothing special for me. A little bit of harshness on the nose in the beginning, quite pleased by the taste, not grassy

Plantation 2003 Trinidad

Fruity rum First Plantation rum in my life, I think this could be a solid 7 if it didn't bore me so much. The rum is nice, the smell is a little bit alcoholic bu

Trois Rivieres VSOP Réserve Spéciale 5-year

Best Agricole I've tasted, not my type I just have to say that Agricole is not at all my favourite type of rum. I just can't enjoy them, but if you like em you should definitely try this on

El Dorado 8-year

Surprised by this almost not sugared El Dorado I was surprised by this El Dorado, it's quite smooth and has no afterburner, you can sip and enjoy it. I don't think it's better than the 12 year.

Flor de Caña Gran Reserva - 7-year

Ok Rum, not sweet It's an everyday rum, not sweetened, it's good enough to sip neat, doesn't pretend to be something else.

Appleton Estate Reserve Blend

Strong but without character Tried this rum at a Christmas dinner, I have the 12 year rare blend at home so I was curious about this one. I found this too much strong and disappoi

Abuelo Gran Reserva 12-year

Tasty and woody, but not my type I do like the wood in this one and I do like the little burn and the taste of caramel and molasses that you have in your mouth just after you have fin

El Dorado 12-year

Very nice sipper Nice sipper, a bit sweet (I know it has a lot of added sugar) but for my personal taste it's bearable. Hints of oak, vanilla and orange peel. Good for

Dictador 12-year

Liquorice If you do like liquorice indeed you should taste this one. I do not like it very much in rum, it covers a lot. Smell was more promising, no sweet in t

Nothing special Maybe a slight better than the extra anejo reserva, it is a bit stronger and aggressive. But not my type, this is not what a rum should taste for me.

Diplomatico Mantuano

Sweet and sharp Too sweet in the nose, surprisingly sharp in the mouth, doesn't have a good finish and leaves your mouth just dry. Won't ever buy a bottle, doesn't wo

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera

Overrated, too much Vanilla Personally I am a big fan of minimum aging politics, so this 23 yo Solera is a big fat lie for me, it is just to impress people that are attracted to

Pyrat XO Reserve

Disappointed, could have been good I'm really disappointed, maybe even pissed, because the actual rum behind the wall of added flavour must be great. Too bad someone dropped a whole ba

Matusalem Gran Reserva 15-year

Alcohol and vanilla Strong smell of alcohol, vanilla is so strong that it feels sweet, very sweet, which is strange, because all hygrometer test results were 0. Vanilla f

Brugal Extra Viejo Gran Reserva

Not so special Not a very special rum, I expected more. It taste like it was diluted. Chocolate is the dominant taste in this rum. No burn. Won't buy the bottle. Not

Barcelo Gran Anejo

Maybe better in cocktails Not so strong, pretty average, maybe a little of vanilla was added. Don't buy if you want a sipper, save your money for something better.

Too dry for me Lucky for me I tried it before buying a bottle because it is too dry and I found it not very pleasant. Also a little bit acid.

Don Papa Small Batch

Artificial flavour You can drink it and enjoy it, but you have to know that you are drinking something that has probably a lot of artificial flavours. Also very sweet an

Pampero Aniversario

Burn burn burn This rum is just a few seconds of rum and then it's gone, and you are left with a burning sensation. No smooth at all.

Zafra Master Reserve 21

Too sweet Didn't like this at all, I was at a rum tasting and this was the biggest disappointment. Maybe the other barrel proof I had earlier didn't help this o

Matusalem 7-year

Added vanilla Not sure in what form but surely someone at some point added in a mysterious way a lot of vanilla in this one. Not a good sipper, the bottle may tempt

Rum only in the process Is this a Rum? Yes, by definition it surely is. But it just stops there. The best thing I can compare it to is cachaça. But it is a second cousin of c

Havana Club Blanco

Do not sip Just use this for cocktails for people who doesn't have any sense of taste for rum at all.

Pampero Anjeo Especial

Even mixed it is bad Just avoid, drink neat coke or just water, it's pointless if you're older than 18

Wishlist

Brand

Type

Country

Average Rating

Total Ratings

Plantation Barbados 5-year

Plantation Gran Anejo Guatemala & Belize

Doorly's 14-year

Flor de Caña 18-year

Rum Nation 2011 Reunion Cask Strength 7-year

Doorly's XO 6-year

El Dorado 21-year

Appleton Estate 21-year

Plantation Barbados 15-year

Ron Zacapa 23 Black Label

Quorhum 30-year

Dominican Republic

Quorhum 23-year

Dominican Republic

Dictador XO Insolent

La Hechicera Extra Anejo

Abuelo Centuria