google-site-verification=oHk_y1_3q2hoJHbB7_i9BCIkl5ml4JwfFFtbL64K0fw

Posting your rating...

Ryan Rosebush

Connoisseur | United States
31 Ratings | 2 Likes

“Avid boater. Island hopper. Rum enthusiast. Pirate-in-training. 🍹☠️”

Brand

Review

Rating

Dictador XO Insolent

Good sipper, if a little pricey Really enjoyed this but not sure I’d keep it in the regular rotation based solely on the price. Very unique Carmel/butterscotch flavor & absolutely ze

El Dorado Special Reserve

Slightly sweet & delicious Extremely smooth & the perfect amount of sweetness. May be my favorite sipper in my bar. At $44, it’s well worth the price to me.

Excellent sipper One of my favorite sippers, along with El Dorado 15. Nice hint of sweetness but not overpowering. Very easy-drinking...

Santa Teresa 1796

Quickly becoming a favorite! Decided to give this one a try recently & so glad I did. Really well balanced rum. Nice blend of molasses-y sweetness & a little spice, and very littl

Diplomatico 2000 Single Vintage Really well balanced special occasion sipper. Just enough sweetness without going overboard & velvety smooth on the palate. Very nice!

Plantation Overproof O.F.T.D.

Bar staple Excellent cocktail rum with great nose & flavor. Not exactly one you’d want to sip on but it is one of my most frequently-used rums when making cockta

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Nice Sipper but Could Be More... Had high hopes for this one but came away slightly disappointed. After a little time in the glass, it opened up nicely and offered a nice flavor profi

Zafra Master Reserve 21

Delicious Sipper & makes an Excellent Rum Old Fashioned Very enjoyable sipper with slight sweetness. Makes an absolutely killer rum old fashioned as well!

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Sweet but smooth sipper Maybe a touch on the sweet side but man, it is velvety smooth. Great on its own, or in a rum old fashioned. Has become a staple in my bar.

Makes an Excellent/Unique Rum & Coke This rum definitely has its place & that place is mixed with Coke. Not terribly enjoyable (to me, at least) on its own but the unique flavor profile l

Kirk and Sweeney

Outstanding! Instantly among my favorites. Remarkably smooth & has a subtle sweetness to it. ZERO burn. The oakiness (is that a word?) on the front end adds nicely

Dry but delicious Considerably drier than I was expecting but extremely drinkable. While perhaps still partial to the 15-year, this presents a nice, complex flavor with

Blue Chair Bay Pineapple Cream

Another Delicious BCB rum cream option Blue Chair Bay is on to something with their rum cream line. While the key Lime & coconut spiced versions are my personal favorites, the pineapple is

Hamilton 86 Demerara

Perfect Tiki Drink Mixer Bar staple for tiki drinks & more. Excellent flavor, yet not overly sweet.

Appleton Estate

Good mixer but not quite a sipping rum I enjoy this rum quite a bit & keep it on hand regularly. That said, it has its place...and that place isn’t sipping.

Diplomatico Distillery Collection No1 Batch Kettle

Needs to Breathe Admittedly didn’t care for this much the first couple of times I had it. After giving it another try & letting it breathe for a bit, it really opened

El Dorado 12 Not bad, but not great either. A little hotter than i was expecting but mellowed out after a little time & an ice cube. Not quite as sugary as I was e

Zaya Gran Reserva

Zaya Nice vanilla & molasses aroma but was a little disappointed with the taste. A touch harsher on the palate than i was expecting & the vanilla came acro

Small skull glass 200px a

Mount Gay XO Extra Old

Nice Sipper Not my favorite but it’s a nice sipper if you’re looking for a rum without much (any?) added sweetness. Needs a little time in the glass to mellow but

Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Cream

Key Lime Pie in a Glass Not really “Rum,” but pretty damn delicious as a dessert drink/night cap.

Blue Chair Bay Coconut Spiced Cream

Total homerun for what it is! BCB is really on to something with their rum creams. By and large, they all have great flavor but this is one of my favorites. Great on ice or in fun

Holy bananas, Batman! While actually pretty smooth sipping, the amount of sweetness/banana on the nose & palate are just a little too much. Will still drink it occasionally

Blue Chair Bay Banana Cream

Least favorite in the BCB rum cream line I’m a fan of the BCB rum cream line in general but, this is probably my least favorite among them. To me, this one tastes the most artificial. It’s st

Small shot glass 200px

Blue Chair Bay Banana

Excellent Bushwhacker “Floater” Sweet but surprisingly not terribly artificial tasting. Good dessert/nightcap beverage. Really adds another level of awesome as a floater on top of a

Arundel Spent some time at this tiny Tortola distillery right after they re-opened post-Irma. Such a simple but well executed operation & the rum was exceptio

Dry & Woody This one is growing on me quite a bit but honestly, I was slightly disappointed the first time I tried it. Needs a little time, and perhaps an ice cub

Mount Gay Eclipse

Mount Gay Eclipse Good everyday rum to keep in the bar but a little to harsh as a sipper (especially with so many other options available). Enjoy mixed...

Small plant 2 200px

Not bad, Not Great Admittedly a little disappointed in this one. Not bad once it opens up for about 15min but, with all of the other choices available, I just don’t find

Captain Morgan Original Spiced Gold

Captain Morgan Tastes like college all over again. Not bad for what it is & always have some in the bar in case there are requests for it, but there are so many bett

Seemed like a good idea...in college Outside of being used in a sweet rum punch or something similar, I don’t see much place for this one. The last time this was a staple in my residence,

Blue Chair Bay Vanilla

Good Island Drink Mixer Zero reason to drink this on its own (IMO, anyway) but certainly has its place. Good supplemental rum when making cocktails.

Small plant 1 200px a

Wishlist