Posting your rating...

Don Tucker

Superstar | Member since 2013 | United States

193 Ratings | 65 Likes | 15 Followers

Brand

Review

Rating

Diplomatico Ambassador Selection

Love this rum My wife brought a bottle back from Miami for my birthday last year. This rum blew me away. I am a big fan of the other Diplomatico offerings, but th

English Harbour 1981 25-year

Excellent I first had this in Antigua after we toured the distillery. My wife just bought me a bottle for Christmas. It's my favorite sipping rum of all.

Zafra Master Reserve 21

One of the Best I just picked up a bottle of this rum in Key West after discussing it with Bahama Bob Leonard. I got it home and tasted it for the first time and I a

Vizcaya VXOP 21

My Favorite Not terribly expensive but so wonderfully sweet. This is my favorite sipping rum. I've found it in NJ and DE.

Edwin Charley Virtue

Awesome Expensive, but worth it. A friend in TCI recommended this and I'm glad I brought one back with me. Now, I wish I had the rest of the collection.

Premium Rum I love the bottle and the rum is top notch. I would drink the Zacapa 23 for half the price, but this is a must have for speical ocassions... like Sat

Don Q Gran Anejo

Wonderful A fabulous premium rum if you have the scratch. It comes in a wonderful box that looks like a silk coffin. I love sipping it on special ocassions.

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera

Love this The Zacapa 23 is one of my favorite sipping rum. I love the Zacapa XO, but this rum is nearly as good for much less. I would keep both in my cabinet

Bambarra Trouvadore 15-year

A Favorite This is one of my favorite rums. The taste is light at first with hints of vanilla and toffee, but it delivers the alcohol on the way down. It has a

One of the best to sip This is a big favorite of mine to sip. You can taste the extra aging in the sherry casks. We love it and it is easily available on the east coast.

Appleton Estate 21-year

Top Shelf Rum Expensive, but worth the price. Incredibily crafted with the right amount of kick to it. One of the best rums in my collection. I enjoy it on speci

Mount Gay 1703 Old Cask

Close to perfect as I've tasted I wish I could rate a 9 1/2. This is a fabulous rum and I love to sip it on special ocassions. You're paying a price for it, but it's worth it.

Rum SixtySix Family Reserve 12-year

Love this rum! I sampled this at Foursquare in Barbados and then brought a bottle home. It is one of my favorite rums. This is not available in the states. Pick u

Angostura 1824 12-year

Great I love this as a sipping rum. We just brought a bottle back from the airport in St Martin. It has become one of my favorites.

Bacardi Reserva Limitada

Near Perfection I just brought a bottle of this back from New York City. I had tasted it before, but this is the first time that I gave it a serious tasting. It is o

Papas Pilar Dark

Love Everything I love everything about this rum. First, the bottle is pure genius. Second, the Hemingway angle is a real winner. Finally, the taste just blows me

St. Nicholas Abbey 10-year

Speical Rum We visited the Abbey and got a bottle of this engraved for us. It is such a great tasting rum. Too bad I finished the bottle.

Seven Fathoms Premium

Very Good Rum My wife bought me a bottle of this for Christmas. It is very tasty straight up. I like the barrel aging under the sea. It is very unique. A great

RL Seale 10-year

Wonderful I found R.L. Seale in DE before we ever visited Foursquare. I really enjoyed sipping this rum. I love Barbados rums and this is one of my favorites.

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Excellent for after dinner I love sipping this rum after dinner. It has a very sweet, molasses dominated taste. It has got plenty of alcohol so that you know that you are drin

Santa Teresa 1796

Great Taste I ordered a bottle online and was very happy that I did. I saw some good reviews and this is a very solid sipping rum. I would put it up with any ru

Bambarra Reserve

Great over ice When we first got to TCI, I tried the Bambarra Reserve first. The resort bar fixed me up with it over ice and a slice of lime. It is a great sipping

Foursquare Spiced

Favorite Spiced Rum This is our favorite spiced rum. We visited the distillery in Barbados on our last trip there and could not get enough of this. Good thing the Total

Havana Club Anejo Reserva

Strong, Solid Rum First tasted Havana Club in the Caymans and then later in Aruba. I like the strength of this rum. It tastes like a powerful Cuban rum with hints of

Chairman's Reserve 4-6 Years

Wonderful Inexpensive Rum This is one of my favorite entry level rums. I can sip it straight, on the rocks, or with coconut water. It is great in Painkillers as well. I brou

Chairman's Reserve Spiced

Top Notch Spiced Rum I noticed the cloves probably more than anything. This is probably my 2nd favorite spiced rum. It is available in the US, generally on the east coas

Pyrat XO Reserve

Pyrat for a Pirate I'm a fan of Pyrat XO. I am looker forward to adding a bottle of the more expensive Cash 1623 to my collection. So many rums, so little time... and

Appleton Estate Extra 12-year

Very Nice Rum I haven't found a bottle of this yet for my collection, but tasted this for the first time at a friend's house. It is a very nice sipping rum. A nic

Brugal Especial Extra Dry

Favorite White This is my favorite white rum to mix. It is so unassuming that it never gets in the way of your cocktails. Makes a wonderful Mojito.

Dos Maderas PX 5+5

Special The 2nd aging gives this rum a very unique test. It's great to sip on.

El Dorado 21-year

Good Rum The bartender at the Rum House in NYC bought the wife and I a pour of this as we were leaving. I have a bottle of the 15 YO at home, but the 21 takes

English Harbour 10-year

Super We brought a bottle back from Antigua and I really enjoyed sipping it. In fact, I enjoyed it so much... it is now gone. I got a bottle of the 1981 f

Flor de Caña 18-year

On my top shelf This rum is on the top shelf in my home cabinet. I loved the 12 YO and this blew me away. A great sipper, but more pricey.

Mount Gay XO Extra Old

Great Sipper I love to sip XO. We got free bottles on our tour of the distillery with the VIP group. It's easy to find in the PA stores and helps me to keep from

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Great Sipper I like this best out of all the Plantation rums I've had so far. A great taste and the bottle reminds me of Vizcaya, another of my favorites.

Plantation 1998 Guadeloupe Single Cask

Super One of my favorite Plantations. You can taste a bit of the cane juice, but this is a nicely aged rum compared to most of the other French island rums

Rhum JM VSOP 4-year

Tasty A very good aged agricole style rum. It's my favorite aged agricole so far to sip.

Centenario 20-year

Surprising I wasn't sure if great rum could come from Costa Rica. Then I tasted a bottle of this. I'm sold. I love sipping this rum!

Zaya Gran Reserva 12-year

Good Sipper A very good sipping rum at a great price. I can find this in all the PA stores.

Plantation 2000 Jamaica

Love it I love the Plantation rums and this is one of my favorites.

R. St Barth Chic

Great taste Brought a bottle back from St Barth. This is my new favorite aged Agricole. A bit pricey at 110 Euro, but I wasn't leaving empty handed.

R. St Barth Authentic 12-year

Very good , but expensive I had a taste down at the store in St. Barth. A great Agricole, but I wasn't tempted to spend 700 Euro for a bottle.

Great Bottle and Very Good Rum I love this bottle, even though I can never easily tell how much I have left. It's a very good sipper.

Angostura 1919 8-year

Fine Rum I bought the 1824 first, so this is a step down for it. However, it is still very good in its own right. I have no problem sipping on either.

Old New Orleans Reserve 10

Great Tasting Rum I first had this rum at the Rum Bar in Key West. I drank it over ice with coconut water and thought it was fabulous. I now have to get a bottle for

Havana Club 7-year

Great Sipper I found a bottle in Aruba and it is a fine sipper. I really like the strength of the Cuban rums. You can tell you are drinking a rum that means busi

Cacique 500 Gran Reserva

Great Taste I found a bottle of this in Aruba and loved the taste of it when I was able to sample it. It reminds me of the great flavor of the Santa Teresa. It'

Pyrat Cask 1623

Think, Sweet Sipper I bought a bottle of this in the Bahamas when we were down for Rum Bahamas. It seems thinker and sweeter than the XO. A very good sipper, but not on

Diplomatico Blanco

Great white rum This is one of my favorite white rums. It mixes clean with just about anything that I have tried.

Papas Pilar Blonde

Excellent Blonde Rum It's not white, it's blonde. A great mixing rum and just a wonderful concept from bottle to name on this one.

Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal

Great White I had the pleasure of tasting this for the first time in the Bahamas at Rum Bahamas. It won 1st place for the whites there for good reason. It is ve

Gosling's Black Seal

Best for Dark N Stormy I love this for my Dark N Stormy's. You can do Myers' Dark, but it is not the same. I do like Old Lahaina Dark, but not as good as Gosling's. Any o

Barbancourt Reserve du Domaine 15-year

Best of Haiti The Estate Reserve is a nice fruity cane juice spirit. It is a very good sipping rum. I am interested in trying the white next for mixing.

Flor de Caña Gran Reserva - 7-year

Good, Every Day Rum I first found the 7 year several years ago when I was returning from Aruba. I've since limited myself to the 18 year and mixed with the Extra Dry 4 y

Pusser's British Navy Blue Label 3-year

Great for Painkillers I love Pusser's in a nice Painkiller. The rum doesn't let the cream of coconut overpower it. PKNY makes a great one.

Appleton Estate Reserve

Good Sipping Rum My wife bought a bottle of the Reserve and the V/X for my birthday last year. I love them both. I can happily sip this to keep from finishing my 21

Appleton Estate V/X

Good to sip, but I wouldn't feel guilty mixing it either. My wife bought a bottle of the Reserve and the V/X for my birthday last year. This is very good to sip, but at a price where mixing isn't a sin eithe

Very good light rum This is a very good light rum. I started drinking it straight, but find it very good for mojitos or anything that calls for a light rum.

Bacardi Oakheart

Fine Spiced Rum A very good spiced rum. It tastes great with cola. Bacardi took their game up a notch with this one.

Cheap Favorite This inexpensive aged rum is a good sipper and great with cola. My wife's favorite with Coke.

Blackwell Black Gold Special Reserve

Great Dark I found this looking for alternative dark rums besides Gosling's and Myers'. I really like it. Great for Dark N Stormy's. I like it for darkening m

Ron Del Barrilito 3 Star

Best Kept Secret of Puerto Rico I found this bottle in Lexington. It's comparable to any of the mid level rums from Puerto Rico, including Barcardi 8 and Don Q Anejo. A great taste

Great Anejo I like this straight pretty well, but try the Jolly Roger for a nice mix. Mix 1 part Anejo, 1 part Banana liqeuer, and 2 parts lemon juice.

Brugal Extra Viejo

Good Sipper I really like to sip this. Pour it over some ice and drop a slice of lime in.

Cruzan Single Barrel

Change of pace A nice sipping rum that is easily available in the PA stores. A nice change of pace to have.

Good Mixer Very light rum that makes a great mixer. Probably my 2nd favorite white so far.

Doorly's XO 6-year

Good Sipper I like sipping some Doorly's as an everyday rum. It's a step up from Old Brigand for the Foursquare products. I like their Rum Sixty Six and R.L. Se

El Dorado Special Reserve 15-year

Very Nice I bought a bottle of this as my introduction to El Dorado. I really like to sip it. The 21 YO is in it's own class, but you will not be disappointed

English Harbour 5-year

Not 1981 or 10 YO, but not bad This is an everyday sipping rum that quenches my thirst while I keep from drinking all the 1981.

Flor de Caña 12-year

Good Find I grabbed this on our first trip to Aruba. I wanted to try a Nicaraguan Rum and this was a perfect starter. Now, that I have tried the 18 YO, I am s

Matusalem Gran Reserva 15-year

Fine Rum A really good sipping rum. I was such a fan of Brugal that I had to try this Dominican Rum as well. It did not disappoint. It's not quite Brugal 18

Mount Gay Eclipse Black

Great Taste I'm a big fan of Mount Gay and I couldn't wait to try the new Black. It did not disappoint. A great mixer at 100 proof to give your cocktails some u

Mount Gay Limited Edition Eclipse Nautical

Love the bottle I probably would normally rate a 6 because of the great Mount Gay products above it, but the bottle rates another star. It's a good mixer and the bot

Pampero Aniversario Reserva Exclusiva

Love the pouch I love the leather pouch my bottle came in. The rum is a very good sipper. It's quite good for the price. I found this in NJ.

Plantation 2000 Barbados

Good Sipper I love the Plantation rums. The Barbados versions are my favorite. The 2000 is a nice sipper at a reasonable price.

Plantation Barbados 5-year

Good Sipper A good sipper so you can drink the XO a special ocassions.

Plantation 1998 Grenada

Good Sipper A little darker than a lot of the other Plantation rums. I find the Grenada 1998 to be a very good neat pour.

Plantation 1998 Nicaragua

Good Sipper It tastes a lot like Flor de Cana, so I assume they distilled this for Plantation. It is a very good sipping rum.

Plantation 2000 Panama

Nice and Light A nice light sipping rum from Plantation by way of Panama.

Plantation 2000 Trinidad

Good Sipper Tastes a lot like 10 Cane, so I assume they distilled this for Plantation. It is a very good, light sipping rum. The extra aging has a fairly dramat

Prichard's Fine

Good Sipper One of the best sipping rums I've tasted from the continental United States. I found this on a trip to Lexington.

Abuelo Reserva Superior 7-year

Good Sipper A good sipping rum. There are better out there, but this one won't let you down.

Kraken Black Spiced

Favorite Black Spiced This is my favorite black spiced rum with Coke.

Atlantico Reserva

Very Good Very good sipping rum!

Nice rum I enjoy this one straight. It has a good clean taste.

Smith and Cross Navy Strength

Stout Navy Rum A good stout navy strength rum, great for mixing. Love it in rum punch.

Good This is a good sipping rum, but overpriced a bit. Not bad but plenty others give you as much or more for less.

Rhum JM Blanc 50

Very good Not a big Agricole fan, but this is my favorite white. Good to mix in a Ti punch or with fruit.

R. St Barth Cool

Good Had a taste at the store in St Barth. It was pretty good. Like it as well as the JM Blanc I think.

Centenario 7-year

Very Good Mixer I'm making all of the drinks in Bahama Bob Leonard's cocktail book and many call for Centernario 7 Year. I love them all and this rum adds just the r

Blue Chair Bay Coconut Spiced

Great Rum and Coke We found a bottle in Cape May, NJ last weekend and it makes a great rum and coke. Just add a little lime and it's a perfect mix.

Fortuna Reserva Exclusiva Anejo 8-year

Great Taste I found a bottle of this rum in Avalon, NJ. It is a good sipper and made some great mixed drinks as well when we needed it.

Pink Pigeon Original

Pleasantly Surprised I wasn't sure what to make of a rum made out in the Indian Ocean, but I really liked the taste. It's a bit different than what I'm used to, but it rea

Renegade 2000 Jamaica

Good Sipper This is good, strong sipper. It's a bit overpriced but hard to find.

Havana Club 3-year

Good to Mix I love this rum mixed with coke or a fruit juice. It can be sipped in a pinch, but it lacks the full flavor and maturity of the 7-Year and the Anjeo

Plantation Trinidad Overproof

Great Overproof I found this bottle at the Liquor Barn in Lexington, KY. They carry all of the best Plantation Rums. I've been using this to mix drinks with some ki

The Lash Spiced

A good spiced rum I have been dying to try this rum for a while and ordered a bottle online. It makes a pretty good rum and coke. I love the color and the flavor.

The Scarlet Ibis Gold

Very good rum, not great I found this rum to be quite good, but not great. My tastes lean more to the sweetness of the El Dorado's or the whiskey like tastes of Bacardi Reser

Good White Rum This is one of the best white rums I've had. Very good to mix with.

Tasty We had this in the Caymans at the Tortuga store. Pretty tasty. I would suspect it is good to mix.

Nice premix We generally like to make our own mojitos, but this will do in a hurry.

Seven Tiki Aged

Nice Rum You have a add a rum from Fiji in your collection. This is a good mixer with cola.

Blue Chair Bay Coconut

Best Coconut Rum I believe this might be the best coconut rum I've tasted so far, not counting it's spiced sibling of course. I'm not crazy about coconut rums, but th

Kilo Kai Spiced

Different Spiced Rum Interesting spiced rum. It is in between the lighter and darker spiced rums. The caramel comes through. I like to mix with cola.

Trader Vics Gold

Pleasantly Surprised I found a bottle of this on the shelves on a visit to Lexington, and thought I would give it a try. I didn't expect much, assuming they were riding o

Admiral Nelson's Premium Vanilla

Great with cola It's not a sipping rum, but it does make a mean mix with cola. One of my favorite mixers with Coke.

Favorite Cachaca I dabble in the Cachacas, but I'm not a huge fan. This is my favorite of the Cachacas. It is a good mixer with fruit.

Myers's Original Dark

Solid Dark Rum This is a very good dark rum that is not bad in Dark N Stormy's, but better suited to rum punches or mai tais.

Solid Rum This is a nice cheap rum to mix with cola. I have sipped it, but Bacardi 8 is the entry level sipping rum for Bacardi.

Good for mixing, fair sipper An inexpensive Anejo from Bacardi. It is OK for sipping, but pretty good in cocktails. The Bacardi Anejo Highball is recommended.

Bacardi Ron Solera 1873

Rich Mixer A very good mixer. Try pairing it with Bacardi Superior to get a little more flavor into your cocktails. The Next Great Shake by Shingo Gokan is a g

Cruzan Pineapple

Pineapple starter A good choice when you want to start off your mixed drink with a pineapple rum.

Nice tropical start I actually had to buy this bottle in the Duty Free in Aruba. I have yet to find it in the PA stores, although they carry many other Cruzan flavoreds.

Diplomatico Reserva

Good, but not Exclusiva It's a very good sip, but I had the Exclusiva first and it just can't compare to its big brother.

Nice Mixer Nice gold mixer. I like the Cristal better to mix, but I use this when I want a little more flavor.

El Dorado 3-year

Good Mixer A good mixer from El Dorado. I couldn't find it very easy in PA, NJ, or DE, but did find it in NYC.

Flor de Caña Extra Dry 4

Good Mixer I am a big fan of Flor de Cana, so I couldn't wait to try their white extra dry. It's a really good mixer with a light taste that stays out of the wa

Mount Gay Eclipse

Good Mixer A good mixer, but the upscale Mount Gay products provide no reason to sip this. I like the Speical Reserve and Sugar Cane Rum as well to mix.

Old Brigand Black Label

Good Rum I'm a big fan of Foursquare. The put out some great products. I have a bottle of Old Brigand Black Label in my collection, mostly for mixing. I lea

Prichard's Cranberry

Good Flavor You do not see many Cranberry rums. This is pretty good and a nice change of pace to sip.

Seven Tiki Spiced

Nice Spice You have a add a rum from Fiji in your collection. This is a good mixer with cola.

Agua Luca Light

Nice Cachaca Good Cachaca to mix with fruit or with a little sugar, lime, and ice.

Good for Caipirinha Good for Caripirinhas.

Captain Morgan Tatoo

Good with Coke If you want a nice dark spiced with Coke, this will do for you.

Captain Morgan Black Spiced

Good Spiced Good with Coke, but Kraken is better in this category.

Bambarra Coconut

Good Mixer I had a sample of this at the bottling plant in TCI. It's a good mixer when you want to start with coconut rum.

Good Rum A good mixing rum. I'm spoiled with Bambarra Reserve and Trouvadore though.

Bambarra Silver

Good Mixer Sampled some of this at the bottling plant in TCI. It would be a good mixer when you don't want the rum to get in the way.

Brinley Gold Coffee

A decent coffee rum I found this in NYC and it's a good tasting coffee rum. I'm looking for mixers to cut down on some of the heavy coffee flavor.

Captain Morgan Lime Bite

Nice Spice Nice take on spiced rum with cola. It's a good change of pace from the regular spiced and cola.

Nice Rum A good rum to sip or to mix. Dominican rums are a favorite of mine.

Unique We found this at Cuba Libre in Philly. I had not seen before. It had a strong finish, but I think further aging would have improved it.

Captain Morgan Private Stock

Surprising A Captain I enjoy drinking straight. A big step up for them.

Not bad I am spoiled by the Gran Anejo, but the Anejo is a fair sipper and good to mix.

Alleyne Arthur's Special Barbados

Not bad A decent rum. Not quite a good sipper but good in drinks.

Saint James Royal Ambre 18-Mois

Not bad Not a huge Agricola fan, but this is very good in Ti punch when in the French islands.

Mount Gay Eclipse Silver

Very good white rum Great to mix with. Mount Gay doesn't make any bad products that I've tasted.

Rum-Bar White Overproof

Not overpowering A great ovenproof to mix in punch. Found this at a state store in South Philly.

Clement VSOP 4-year

A sipper This is one of the few agricoles that I enjoy sipping. Less sweet and closer to a whiskey.

Depaz Blue Cane Amber 1-year

Nice Agricole I found this in DE. It is good in cola and would likely be good in mojitos as someone else mentioned.

Taylor’s Velvet Falernum

Tasty Had this as a mixer at the distillery. It added great flavor. Hard to find near PA. Found an online site that sells it. I also found a Total Wine

Blackbeard Spiced

Good spiced Good spiced with cola. Found a bottle in NJ.

Brinley Gold Shipwreck Spiced

Tasty Spiced Visited St Kitts and loved this. Easily found in PA stores. Great with coke.

Pére Labat Blanc 59

Not bad Brought a bottle back from St Martin. It was pretty good to mix with fruit juices.

Not bad Bought a bottle in St Martin. It was good mixed with fruit juices.

Rum Jumbie Liqueur

Tasty Bought a bottle in St Martin. Very good to mix with 7 up. Love the bottle with the hat.

Cruzan Black Strap

Strong Dark Rum Of the dark rums I have tried to so far, this has the strongest molasses taste. It gives the Dark and Stormy a different taste than my usual Gosling'

Flor de Caña Gold 4

Good Mixer I'm a fan of Flor de Cana. The 4 year gold makes a good mixer. I can sip it in a pinch, but prefer to mix it.

Brinley Gold Vanilla

Tasty with Cola I love how the thick vanilla rum mixes with cola. It looks like some of the PA stores have replaced the Shipwreck Spiced with this one. I want both

Blue Chair Bay White

Nice, Clean White Rum I found a bottle the first week it was released in Cherry Hill, NJ. It's a very clean white rum that makes a good mixer. Great with fruity drinks th

Atlantico Platino

Good Light Rum This is a very good light rum for mixing in cocktails. It has a very tame flavor and will mix well with about anything.

Barbancourt 5 Star Reserve Especiale 8-year

Good Agricole This is a good sipping rum in a pinch. It pales in comparison to the 15 year, but it mature enough to sip.

Havana Club Blanco

Smooth Mixer I like the clean taste of this rum, but it needs to be mix for full affect. I drank this with various fruit juices in Aruba. It is also a high price

Bacardi Superior

Light and Easy The standard mixer you should always have a large bottle of this in your cabinet when you want cocktails that let the ingredients do the talking. A B

Barrel House Oak

Stick with Bourbon Growing up in Kentucky, I was excited when I found this on the shelves on a visit to Lexington. I was a little disappointed. The rum just wasn't swe

Appleton Estate Special Gold

Great Entry Level I hate to rate this just a 5 considering it is a great entry level rum, but the rest of the Appleton greatness has spoiled me. I would keep a bottle

Put some fire in your punch A good gold overproof to prop up your drinks. Float it on a Mai Tai.

Good Entry Level Gold Mix with coke for the Cuba Libre. Try it in a Mai Tai, maybe float some 151 if you need more kick.

Cruzan 9 Spiced

Decent Spiced Not a bad spiced rum to have with cola. Not one of my favorites, but a lot better than most.

Fine for mixing I can take or leave coconut rum in general, but this is as good as any to start your fruit drinks.

Stroh Original 80

Kickin Bring the fire. Good for mixed drinks with high octane.

Tortuga Coconut

Not bad Not bad for a coconut rum. Had this at the Tortuga store in the Caymans.

Good Spiced Had a sample in the Caynans. Not bad for mixing with cola.

Nice mixer Had some at the distillery in St. Lucia, and them brought a small bottle back from TCI. Good to mix, sip in a pinch.

Captain Morgan 100

Hot Spiced Like the extra alcohol with spice. Kicks up the rum and cola.

Captain Morgan Silver Spiced

Unassuming Spiced Good for mixing with fruit for a spicy punch.

Captain Morgan Spiced

Standard Spiced There are many others I prefer, including Captains, but this will do in a pinch.

Cockspur 5 Star Fine

Not bad Not too bad with cola. Visited the distillery in Barbados. More beach club than anything.

Good Mixer Good mixer. Not quite a good sipper.

Ron Viejo de Caldas 3-year

So so An interesting taste, but I'd like to try a longer aged product for sipping.

Cavalier Antigua White 2-year

Not Bad Had this at the distillery store in Antigua. It is a decent rum and would make a good mixer.

Old School Reminds me of an old school Puerto Rican local rum. Not bad to mix with, but not a sipper. After finding several great cocktails to mix Caliche wi

Good mixer Good in rum punch.

Neisson Blanc 50

Strong Agricole One of the better white agricoles that I have had. Not a huge fan, but good to mix with fruit.

Oronoco Fazenda Reserva

Good light rum This is a pretty good mixer. It is easily available in the PA stores.

Sailor Jerry Spiced

Good Spiced My wife really likes the sailor with cola. I find it pretty good, but not in my top 3-5 spiced rums.

Not bad spiced Tasted it for the first time at the distillery in St. Lucia. Found a small bottle in TCI that formed a larger bottle with Bounty and Chairman Reserve

Cheap Mixer We had this in St Martin at the Le Esplanade bar. It's a cheap mixer that will do in a pinch. Be bought a pint to bring home since I haven't seen it

Mixer The flavored Bacardi's all add something to a drink when you wish. The Limon is good with Coke.

Good with 7 Up I like the Razz with 7 Up. I could never find a normal 750 ml bottle at the local Giant, so I had to buy the last 1.5 liter. Now, they don't stock i

Crisp Taste Nice orange flavored rum to mix with fruit juices and forgoing orange juice to keep the acidic content down.

Bacardi Peach Red

Mixer You don't see a lot of peach rum, so use this as a mixer when you just want a bit of peach flavor in your fruity drink.

Bacardi Big Apple

Love it I love the Big Apple and 7 Up. It's a nice simple summer drink to quench the thirst.

Bacardi Grand Melon

Another unusual flavor You aren't going to see many watermelon flavored rum. I love this with 7 Up. I'll be trying these flavors in all sorts of mixed drinks in the summer

Bacardi Dragon Berry

Wonderful Strawberry I love this with 7 Up. I will be looking for all sorts of fruit mixes with this one.

Bacardi Torched Cherry

Cherry Goodness My wife loves this in a cherry limeade. I love it in 7 Up. The cherry flavor opens up a lot of mixing opportunities.

Whaler's Killer Coconut

Decent Coconut Rum I had to buy a bottle for my collection and it's not bad. It overwhelms a bit with the coconut, but not bad in a mixed drink.

Barbancourt 3 Star 4-year

Overshadowed by Older Siblings Barbancourt makes some fine aged rums. The 3 star is not quite a sipping rum, better used in cocktails.

Standard Basic coconut rum, good for piña coladas.

Aguardiente Cristal

Interesting Take I was curious and picked up a bottle in Lexington. The Licorice flavor was very apparent. I wasn't bad overall and a fresh take on can spirits that

Dillon Blanc 50

Strong A strong Agricole. I've mixed with fruit for a decent drink.

Entry Level Rum Travelling through West Virginia I saw this rum and it was cheap, so I added to my collection. It was nothing to write home about, but I didn't expec

Negrita Bardinet Signature Dark 2-year

Dark Agricole I'm not sure about a dark agricole. I guess it would be nice to cook with. I'm searching for mixers to see if I can find its compliments.

Wishlist

Brand

Type

Country

Average Rating

Total Ratings

Angostura Legacy

Trinidad and Tobago

Havana Club Selección de Maestros

Havana Club Maximo Extra Anejo

Appleton Estate Limited Edition 30-year

Appleton Estate 50-year

Bundaberg Reserve

Bundaberg 10-year

RumRanking:

Superstar

Don Tucker rated Plantation 3 Stars Artisanal over 7 years ago
Don Tucker rated Papas Pilar Blonde over 7 years ago
Don Tucker rated Papas Pilar Dark over 7 years ago
Don Tucker rated Diplomatico Blanco over 7 years ago
Don Tucker rated Diplomatico Ambassador Selection over 7 years ago