Go Premium: no ads, rum prices, unlock Flair, +more
Posting your rating...
Aficionado | United States
Best I’ve had so far
I drink my rum neat. I’ve tried several mid to high end sipping rums that I would consider 9’s. Some have come close to a 10 but I am the kind of pers
After trying a bottle of 20 year solera from Dictador I thought I would give this a go. Unlike the 20 year old, this one has a subtle aroma. It is swe
25-Year Port Finish
After trying Opthimus 25 year and rating it a well deserved 10 I decided to try another offering from Oliver. Side by side they are very close. Both h
Master Reserve 21
An excellent choice
Overall this rum has a lot going for it. It is smooth and has good flavor. Not overly powerful up front, has very little lingering taste, and not very
Great from start to finish. Robust and smooth with full flavor. Great choice for a neat sipper.
The presentation of this rum is excellent. The color is very deep red and brown, smell is subtle and enticing. Great initial flavor, exceptionally smo
XO 20th Anniversary
I’ve not tried a rum yet that deserves a 10 rating. I’ve rated some 9’s before and believe there is always something better. This however is as close
The title says it all. Great from start to finish! Drink it neat and it will not disappoint. A must try for everyone.
Plantation Trinidad 2003
Great all around!
12 year double aged. Having tried most of the Plantation line up with little disappointment I bought a bottle of this. For a 12 year aged rum it has t
Another great choice from Oliver & Oliver
Having tried and rated both the 25 year and 25 year port finish I thought I would try this. All around great. Smooth, great sweet taste with just a li
Barbados XO Single Cask 2018
Another great rum from Plantation
Single cask collection 2018. Made at the West Indies Rum Distillery. It says double aged but no indication of how many years. States first in Bourbon
Another regional offering from Plantation. At only 9 years aged it is still a very good rum to drink neat.
Single cask Panama 12 year (Bottled exclusively for Davidsons Liquors)
Smokey and smooth
This was recommended to me at my local go to store Davidson’s Liquors in Colorado. Bottled for them exclusively by Plantation. 2018 limited release si
In the glass it has a very nice yet somewhat subtle aroma. Taste is smooth and sweet without being overbearing. You must like sweet and heavier rums t
This rum has a lot going for it. The aromas coming out of the freshly uncorked bottle is amazing. In the glass it has great dark color, rich flavors a
Zinfandel Cask Blend 11-Year
I was apprehensive to give this a try. No added sugar or flavors, sounds bland. Wow was I wrong. Subtle taste, great aroma, smooth finish. Overall a e
I am a big fan of the Zacapa line of rum. The smoky flavor and intensity really adds a lot of character to this rum. A very different and bold taste c
Great all around
This is a staple in my cabinet. A great rum to break in new people to drinking rum. Not too harsh or overbearing and quite smooth. An excellent value
Some of the best
Without breaking the bank Solera 23 is one of the best out there. Not too strong, full of flavor, and smooth. An excellent choice for someone wanting
XO Extra Old
All around good
This rum has a nice subtle taste and is quite smooth. It’s a blended rum with 7 to 15 year aged rums being used. Great color and overall nice to sip n
Great aroma, but...
Right out of the gate this rum starts off with a very sweet and pleasant aroma. The taste however is a little lacking. Even after sitting a while ther
The Real McCoy
I was on the fence about trying this one after reading the reviews, but finally decided to give it a try. If I had to rate it right out of the bottle
This is a very easy sipping rum for sure. However, the price puts it in a category with a lot of other brands that could be considered slightly better
Jack O Blast Spiced
Great seasonal drink
I am a huge fan of anything pumpkin flavored. I was glad to see that captain brought this back this year. I bought 6 bottles last year and was running
Another great offering
I’m a big fan of Plantaion rum. This is a double aged 14 year rum. Not overbearing with the oak casks or too sweet from the Ferrand barrels. A nice ar
The Real McCoy
10-Year Virgin Oak
Another great offering from The Real McCoy
Limited edition 10 year. Overall a very nice sipping rum.
Kirk and Sweeney
A cut above
This is a much better offering than the 18 year old. Nice from start to finish.
I’m not much for spiced rum. A friend of mine brought a bottle of this back for me as a gift. It is very different from the usual Captain Morgan’s or
Master Blender’s Special Edition 2017
Found this new El Dorado special edition in my local store. I’ve never been a big fan of El Dorado rum but I like to try anything special edition. The
Saw this bottle at a local store and looked it up to see how it was rated. Only finding one rating I was dubious, but thought the risk was worth it se
Reserva Superior 7-Year
Recently tried a glass of this neat. Was what I expected from a 7 year rum. Not overly smooth or flavorful but not bland and harsh either. All around
Great from start to finish!
Typically I would not put Captain Morgan’s in the sipping neat category. Although this stuff has not been on the shelf for years and is almost impossi
Kirk and Sweeney
It’s a good rum with a lot of flavor and a little bite. However, I would say it is priced in the market where there are other brands and choices to co
If you like coconut.....
I like that Captain Morgan puts out limited edition rum in different flavors. Once in while it is nice just to have a fun cocktail with friends and fa
Another very good offering
Another limited edition gone forever. A few bottles still can be found online, but long gone from store shelves. Although I did not like this as much
Plenty of flavor
This rum is good neat or on the rocks. Start to finish it has great flavor. A contrast to other dark rums in the same price range. Worth a try.
Flor de Cana
Was expecting more
Don't get me wrong this is a very good sipping rum. It is very smooth and balanced. It is just a little to subtle on taste for my liking. Good, yes, b
Maison Centenaire 30 year
I have not seen this in too many stores and thought I would give it a try. Not familiar with the brand and had not tried French rum. There also was ve
Light on the color, ok on the taste and smoothness. About what I would expect from a bottle at this price. Not great but passable.
8 Gran Reserva
I've never been a big Bacardi fan but a friend of mine got a bottle of this so I gave it a try. I drink my rum neat so that is the way I tried this on
I’m not one for mixing my rum but if you are looking for a spiced rum for mixing this will definitely add some zing to your beverage.
This was my first experience with El Dorado. Maybe starting with a 12 year was a mistake. This brand gets a lot of good reviews. To harsh and not very
A little disappointed
I have tried to like rum from this region and I always end up expecting more. It ranks just ok in my book. Not a very good sipper, neat. Maybe it’s ok
A little disappointed
Not too many stores carry this brand so when I came across a bottle I grabbed it. This has a fairly high rating so I thought it would be worth the ris
Not quite as good as Reserva Exclusiva. I prefer to drink all my rum neat. Overall this is a good rum especially for the price. I find it better over
Better out there
The color should have been an indicator from the start. Very light and lacking color. Smell was ok but very harsh and lacking flavor. Maybe good for m
Not one for drinking neat. Over ice it is a tolerable drink. Initial smell is very strong and industrial like. Mild taste with a lasting finish. Might
Not my favorite Captain
Don't get me wrong, Captain Morgan produces a lot of good products. I have tried, and rated a lot of their rum. This one however falls short of my exp
Better than some
Side by side with kraken it’s tough to tell the difference, except this one is not as bad. Drinkable if you had to, in a mix it might be ok.
Mix it up
This should be the standard for a mixing spiced rum. Who can argue with a 100 proof rum and coke.
Not for everyone, or anyone.
Captain Morgan brings out special products every so often and then they are gone. Some are quite good, others not so much. This is marginal at best, u
With all the spiced rum out there my only question is why? Not for me for sure.
Far North Spirits
Alander Nordic Rum
Saw this at a local store recently. Never heard of Nordic rum or Alander brand. Comes from Minnesota. The bottle is cool but hides a monster. I unders
2 days ago
Siesta Key Spiced
2 months ago
Kirk and Sweeney 23-Year
2 months ago
Plantation Barbados XO Single Cask 2018
3 months ago
Plantation Plantation Trinidad 2003
3 months ago
See more rum ratings