Nathan Hevenstone

I'm getting into rum. Suggestions are always welcome! Oh, and a warning: I'm a Social Justice Warrior and proud of it. Also... from now on, for premium rums, if they've been tested and found to potentially have a lot of added sugar, my max rating for them will be 7. I do still enjoy such rums (like Zacapa's Solera 23), but I can't give them a higher rating in good faith, especially as they often aren't operating in good faith.

Cabinet List

Brand

Review

Rating

Date

Likes

Foursquare 2005 12-year

I'm Actually Sad About This One... Ratings are relatively high for it, and descriptions are well within my palate, so I expected to like it a lot better than I did. Foursquare has a rep

6

03/22/2020

0

Botran Solera Reserva 15-year

Suprising for the Price! I spent $23 US on this, and I expected something more along the lines of a mixer for that price. Instead, what I got was a delicious, complex, smooth

8

11/20/2016

0

Richland 2016 Estate Old South Georgia Classic Reserve Single Barrel Select 6-year

A Unique, Almost Effervescent Experience It was a strange experience sipping this for the first time. It has a knockback, but I've never had a knockback that disappeared almost as fast as it

9

02/05/2022

0

Foursquare 2008 Premise 10-year

My *Current* Favorite Rum I'll be trying another one of their's soon, but this might be my all-time favorite rum... at least for right now. I don't know what it is, but spir

9

02/22/2020

0

Appleton Estate Rare Blend 12-year

Now This is a Good Sipper Especially for that price! To be fair, I can't really claim that this Appleton's "best offering", because this is my first from them. But it's one

9

01/03/2020

3

Zafra Master Reserve 21

My Journey Continues... Into This I'm continuing my journey into the world of rum and wow... I'm not sure I even know what to say about this, other than "incredible". Zacapa is still m

9

06/27/2015

0

Centenario 20-year

My First Centenario This has definitely piqued my interest in Centenario's rums. While certainly not the best rum I've ever had, this one is very good. I really enjoy eve

8

01/03/2020

0

Kirk and Sweeney 23-year

One of the Better Rums I've Tried Thankfully, based on hydrometer tests, this ones got either very little, or no additives. So it's sweetness, to my palate, anyways, is a pleasant surp

8

01/03/2020

0

Captain Morgan Private Stock

Great Captain Morgan Now this I found to be quite good. I'd probably call this the best of the rums I've tried (which, admittedly, are mainly Captain Morgan, Sailor Jerry,

8

02/15/2015

0

Clement VSOP 4-year

Surprised at the Ratings... This is a Really Good One! I really enjoy this one. It has a natural sweetness to it that I enjoy, and the medicinal quality is minimal. Non non-existent, but minimal enough to

7

01/03/2020

0

Cayman Reef Double Black

A Mixer, But a Good One I much prefer this as a mixing rum. As a sipping rum, it definitely falls short, but in a cocktail or even a basic rum and coke, it's quite delicious.

7

01/03/2020

0

Kirk and Sweeney 12-year

Probably the Worst... But it's Still Really Good If I were going to rank the three K&S's I've tried, it'd go 23, 18, and 12. 12 is definitely the worst of the three for me. But that isn't saying m

7

01/03/2020

0

Kirk and Sweeney 18-year

A Good One... A Lot Like the 23 To be entirely honest, this one is similar to the 23. The main difference between the two is that the 23 is somewhat smoother, as age tends to do to a

7

01/03/2020

0

Zaya Gran Reserva 12-year

Wow (Update January 3, 2020: So... after reading through the hydrometer tests, I unfortunately discovered that Zaya is a company that absolutely loads the

7

06/04/2015

0

Sailor Jerry Spiced

A Decent Spiced Rum It's probably the best spiced rum of the ones I've tried, but I'm willing to bet there's better out there. I like using it in mixed drinks.

7

02/15/2015

0

Captain Morgan Limited Edition

Could Have Been Better... ... if you could actually taste the sherry. Despite that, it is a good rum. I enjoy it, even for sipping... but on the rocks.

7

02/15/2015

0

Captain Morgan Tatoo

Wow. I Like It. I guess I don't have the palate a lot of rum drinkers have? I love Tattoo. To be fair, I use this mostly for cola and mixed drinks as opposed to sippi

7

02/15/2015

0

Captain Morgan Dark

My First Rum This was the rum that kick-started my interest in rum, but that took a long time to simmer, and so I'm a noob to it. I do like this rum, but Captai

7

02/15/2015

0

RL Seale ABV 43 10-year

A Very Good, High-End Mixer; Not for Sipping So I recently tried this rum and... you know what? It was good. It was really good. I believe this would taste like heaven in some coke. Or perhaps a

7

07/09/2015

1

Espirito XVI Cavaleiro

A Nice, Bourbony Rum My dad liked it, which means it must be good because he doesn't usually like rum... Admittedly, this is my first cachaça, but it's an amazing intro

7

11/17/2018

0

Ron Zacapa 23 Solera

My Rum World Has Changed (Update January 3, 2020: So... after reading through the hydrometer tests, I unfortunately discovered that Ron Zacapa is a company that absolutely loa

7

03/24/2015

41

Mount Gay Black Barrel

It's Not That Bad! I did find this one to be medicinal, but not in a distracting way like some mixing rums. This one is definitely a sipper, although I wouldn't be again

6

01/03/2020

0

Castillo Silver

Perfect For Mixing I got it to make frozen daiquiris with. Would I drink it straight? No. That's very obviously not what it's for. But as a mixer, I actually like

6

04/20/2019

0

Kaniche XO

[Good] for the Price (Update January 3, 2020: So... after reading through the hydrometer tests, I unfortunately discovered that Kaniche is a company that absolutely loads

6

12/06/2015

0

Captain Morgan Silver Spiced

A Spiced Rum for Mixing You'll probably end up using this is daiquiris and the like. Goes good in Long Island Iced Tea and similar drinks, as well. While it has a good flavor

6

02/15/2015

0

10 Cane Light

A Decent Mixer It wasn't bad in Coke. I would not drink it straight, though.

6

04/05/2015

0

Ron Zacapa Edicion Negra

Good, Not Great... Probably Has Additives Sadly, it seems this Zacapa hasn't been subject to one of the many hydrometer tests, but given their propensity for loading their rums with sugars and

5

01/03/2020

0

Captain Morgan 100

Not Bad Basically, this is a "get wasted at a party" rum. You use it for shots, games, contests, and other stuff like that. I do like it, but since I'm not th

5

02/15/2015

0

Wishlist

Brand

Type

Country

Average Rating

Total Ratings

Panama-Pacific 23-year

Aged

Panama

8.1

25

Montanya Oro Dark

Gold

United States

6.2

16

Montanya Exclusiva

Aged

United States

8.7

4

Richland Single Estate Old Georgia

Gold

United States

6.9

50

Foursquare Hereditas 14-year

Aged

Barbados

8.9

16

Mainbrace Premium Spliced

Gold

United Kingdom

0.0

0

Foursquare Triptych 2004-2005-2007 Released by Velier 9-year

Aged

Barbados

8.9

23

Equiano Original 8-year

Aged

Mauritius

7.6

75

Foursquare 2006 Redoutable 14-year

Aged

Barbados

9.2

38

Foursquare 2008 Diadem 12-year

Aged

Barbados

8.6

5

Foursquare 2004 Patrimonio Released by Velier 15-year

Aged

Barbados

9.1

12

Mount Gay XO The Peat Smoke Expression

Aged

Barbados

6.8

11

Plantation Extréme No.3 Jamaica Long Pond ITP 22-year

Aged

Multiple

9.4

5

Plantation Extreme NO.3 Jamaica Long Pond HJC 22-year

Aged

Multiple

8.5

8

El Dorado 1988 25-year

Aged

Guyana

9.7

21

El Dorado 1986 25-year

Aged

Guyana

9.0

23

El Dorado 1980 25-year

Aged

Guyana

9.8

18

El Dorado Millenium 25

Aged

Guyana

9.1

30

Ron Del Barrilito Reserva Suprema 5 Star

Aged

Puerto Rico

9.3

8

Dok Trelawny

Light

Jamaica

9.0

1

XXX 2010 Three

Dark

Dominican Republic

0.0

0

Fine Drams 2015 Two 14-year

Dark

Denmark

0.0

0

Zafra Master Reserve 30-year

Aged

Panama

9.4

88

Cubaney Centenario 25-30-Year

Aged

Dominican Republic

9.2

103

Facundo Exquisito

Aged

Puerto Rico

8.5

44

Facundo Eximo

Aged

Puerto Rico

7.9

36

Facundo Neo

Light

Puerto Rico

5.6

14

Damoiseau VSOP 4-year

Agricole

Guadeloupe

6.9

35

Dzama Cuvee Noire Prestige

Aged

Madagascar

6.9

49

Sag Harbor Old Whalers Style

Gold

United States

4.5

5

Barbancourt 3 Star 4-year

Gold

Haiti

5.0

59

Atlantico Reserva

Gold

Dominican Republic

6.1

56

Foursquare 2005 Port Cask Finish 9-year

Aged

Barbados

8.2

97

Foursquare 1998 10-year

Aged

Barbados

7.0

1

Ron Zacapa XO

Aged

Guatemala

8.6

784

Ron Zacapa Centenario 23

Aged

Guatemala

8.6

74

Ron Zacapa 23 Black Label

Aged

Guatemala

8.9

36

Ron Zacapa Centenario XO Premio Platino

Aged

Guatemala

8.8

39

Ron Zacapa 30 Aniversario

Aged

Guatemala

9.2

51

Ron Zacapa 2014 Reserva Limitada

Aged

Guatemala

7.9

61

Ron Zacapa Etiqueta Negra

Aged

Guatemala

7.7

67

Ron Zacapa Centenario 15

Aged

Guatemala

7.1

89

Ron Zacapa Straight from the Cask Special Edition

Aged

Guatemala

9.3

48

Ron Zacapa 2013 Reserva Limitada

Aged

Guatemala

8.4

26

Captain Morgan 1671

Spiced

Puerto Rico

7.1

77

Diplomatico Ambassador Selection

Aged

Venezuela

9.0

247

El Dorado 21-year

Aged

Guyana

8.4

433

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary

Aged

Multiple

8.4

1686

Appleton Estate 21-year

Aged

Jamaica

8.3

329

Vizcaya VXOP 21

Aged

Dominican Republic

7.8

159

Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva

Aged

Venezuela

7.9

2789

Gosling's Family Reserve Old

Aged

Bermuda

7.7

226

Angostura 1824 12-year

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

7.6

254

Angostura Legacy

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

0.0

2

Abuelo Gran Reserva 12-year

Aged

Panama

7.4

408

Abuelo Centuria

Aged

Panama

8.7

167

Arcane Extraroma 12-year

Aged

Mauritius

6.9

182

Millonario Reserva Especial 15

Aged

Peru

7.8

413

Flor de Caña Añejo Clásico 5-year

Gold

Nicaragua

5.4

79

Flor de Caña 25-year

Aged

Nicaragua

8.5

175

Brugal Siglo de Oro

Aged

Dominican Republic

7.9

85

Santa Teresa 1796

Aged

Venezuela

7.6

671

Havana Club Selección de Maestros

Aged

Cuba

7.5

416

Admiral Rodney Extra Old 12-year

Aged

Saint Lucia

7.7

183

Admiral Nelson's Premium Vanilla

Flavored

United States

4.7

5

Admiral Nelson's Premium Raspberry

Flavored

United States

1.0

2

Dos Maderas PX 5+5

Aged

Barbados

7.6

681

Pusser's British Navy Blue Label 40 3-year

Aged

Virgin Islands, British

6.8

428

Flor de Caña 18-year

Aged

Nicaragua

7.3

536

Mount Gay XO Extra Old

Aged

Barbados

7.8

723

Pampero Aniversario Reserva Exclusiva

Aged

Venezuela

7.1

827

Appleton Estate 50-year

Aged

Jamaica

9.2

13

Skotlander Handcrafted I

Light

Denmark

5.3

12

Bayou Spiced

Spiced

United States

7.0

121

Bacardi de Maestros de Ron MMXII

Aged

Puerto Rico

10.0

5

Pyrat Cask 1623

Aged

Anguilla

8.5

69

Pyrat XO Reserve

Gold

Anguilla

6.1

1136

Cavalier Antigua 151 Proof 2-year

Overproof

Antigua and Barbuda

7.3

3

English Harbour 10-year

Aged

Antigua and Barbuda

7.5

69

English Harbour 5-year

Aged

Antigua and Barbuda

6.5

181

Isla Ñ Gold

Gold

Argentina

5.3

3

Ricardo Dark

Dark

Bahamas

5.7

3

Ricardo White

Light

Bahamas

4.5

2

Mount Gay 1703 Old Cask

Aged

Barbados

7.9

133

Ron Miel Tobacco Honey

Flavored

Spain

6.8

14

Dictador XO Insolent

Aged

Colombia

8.4

166

La Hechicera Extra Anejo

Aged

Colombia

7.6

230

Pyrat Pistol

Gold

Anguilla

6.7

17

New Holland Superior Single Barrel

Gold

United States

7.5

2

Appleton Estate Exclusive

Aged

Jamaica

8.4

11

Dictador XO Perpetual

Aged

Colombia

8.3

103

English Harbour 1981 25-year

Aged

Antigua and Barbuda

8.9

37

Juan Santos 21-year

Aged

Colombia

7.8

10

Legendario Elixir de Cuba 7-year

Gold

Cuba

6.3

389

Havana Club 15-year

Aged

Cuba

7.9

76

Santiago de Cuba Anejo

Gold

Cuba

6.6

170

Santiago de Cuba Anejo Superior 11-year

Aged

Cuba

7.9

93

Mulata Anejo 15-year

Aged

Cuba

7.0

43

Santiago de Cuba Extra Anejo 20-year

Aged

Cuba

8.7

36

Edmundo Dantes 15-year

Aged

Cuba

7.9

22

Legendario Añejo Blanco

Light

Cuba

5.9

18

Havana Club Maximo Extra Anejo

Aged

Cuba

8.9

19

Angostura Single Barrel Reserve

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

7.1

21

St. George California Reserve

Aged

United States

4.5

5

To Add Ron Dorado

Gold

France

9.0

2

Legendario Gran Reserva 15-year

Aged

Cuba

8.5

15

Clement 1970 21-year

Agricole

Martinique

8.4

8

Domaine de Severin Rhum Vieux 6-year

Agricole

Guadeloupe

5.8

10

La Belle Cabresse Rhum Agricole Blanc

Agricole

Guyana

6.8

14

Old Sam Rhum Demerara

Aged

Guyana

6.8

25

Pere Labat Blanc 59

Agricole

Guadeloupe

7.7

55

Rhum JM 2001 9-year

Agricole

Martinique

8.5

13

Quorhum 23-year

Aged

Dominican Republic

7.8

122

Rhum JM XO 6-year

Agricole

Martinique

7.3

100

Rhum JM Cuvee du Fondateur 10-year

Agricole

Martinique

8.6

9

La Favorite La Flibuste

Agricole

Martinique

9.4

98

El Dorado 12-year

Aged

Guyana

7.6

1336

El Dorado Special Reserve 15-year

Aged

Guyana

8.0

935

Quorhum 30-year

Aged

Dominican Republic

9.0

357

Barbancourt Reserve du Domaine 15-year

Aged

Haiti

7.5

106

Diplomatico 2000

Aged

Venezuela

9.2

137

Millonario XO

Aged

Peru

8.7

357

Don Q Gran Anejo

Aged

Puerto Rico

7.4

173

Bacardi Reserva Limitada

Aged

Puerto Rico

7.7

82

Centenario 25-year

Aged

Costa Rica

8.6

200

Origenes Don Pancho Reserva Especial 18-year

Aged

Panama

7.8

90

Pusser's Overproof

Overproof

Virgin Islands, British

7.2

36

Havana Club Anejo Reserva

Gold

Cuba

6.3

208

Appleton Estate Signature Marque

Aged

Jamaica

6.5

2

Appleton Estate Master Blender's Legacy

Aged

Jamaica

8.8

14

El Dorado EHP Single Barrel

Aged

Guyana

8.0

23

Porfidio Single Barrel Anejo

Gold

Mexico

6.0

1

El Dorado Single Barrel

Aged

Guyana

7.0

5

El Dorado ICBU Single Barrel

Aged

Guyana

7.6

14

Mocambo Single Barrel 15-year

Aged

Mexico

5.6

19

Cruzan Single Barrel

Aged

Virgin Islands, U.S.

7.0

142

New Grove 2004 Single Barrel

Aged

Mauritius

8.1

7

Phraya Gold

Gold

Thailand

6.8

27

Santa Teresa Bicentenario A.J. Vollmer

Aged

Venezuela

7.2

13

Santa Teresa Gran Reserva Linaje

Aged

Venezuela

6.7

23

Privateer Silver Reserve

Light

United States

7.3

12

Montanya Platino Light

Light

United States

6.3

11

Appleton Estate 250th Anniversary

Aged

Jamaica

7.5

2

Dark Matter Spiced

Spiced

United Kingdom

6.0

52

Dark Matter White

Light

United Kingdom

0.0

0

Tres Hombres 2014 Captain's Choice

Gold

Multiple

9.3

9

Appleton Estate Extra 12-year

Aged

Jamaica

7.0

661

Plantation XO 20th Anniversary (old bottle)

Aged

Multiple

8.3

146

Taildragger Amber

Gold

United States

7.0

8

Smith and Cross Traditional Jamaica Navy Strength

Aged

Jamaica

7.6

330

Appleton Estate Limited Edition 30-year

Aged

Jamaica

8.8

27

Bristol Classic 1980 Port Morant Demerara

Gold

United Kingdom

7.0

1

Pusser's British Navy ”Nelson’s Blood” 15-year

Aged

Virgin Islands, British

7.9

158

Caroni 1994 Trinidad

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

9.8

5

Caroni 12-year

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

7.6

58

Caroni 15-year

Aged

Trinidad and Tobago

8.2

57

Rum Nation 1998 Caroni 16-year

Aged

Italy

7.4

22

Premium Harrogate Honey

Flavored

United Kingdom

0.0

0