Go Premium: no ads, rum prices, unlock Flair, +more
Posting your rating...
Veteran | United States
Not many better
The color is a beautiful caramel mahogany. You get a hint of the barrel to the nose with a vanilla, syrup and woodsy smell that take you through the w
Smooth as smooth can get. Thou I didn’t get a ton of flavor notes but smoothness accounts for something
Nose has a wood, spicy light alcohol smell with light sweetness. Taste is smooth with caramel, vanilla candy like flavor. I did it neat and it was won
23 Black Label
Lighter color than expected but has that amber look. Sweet to the nose. Sweet flavor. Overall really good. Had on rocks and vanilla and fruity flavors
Cuba Libre El Dorado
El dorado 15
Delicious nose. Vanilla and banana taste. Smooth, really good sweetness and no burn. Excellent neat
Spanish Sherry Cask Finished
Pilar sherry cask finish
Nice aroma of sweet caramel, vanilla and almond. Very delicious sipper where all these flavors come out along with a little nuttiness.
Abuelo 12 yr
I felt it had caramel notes. Very smooth and tasty.
Kirk and Sweeney
Kirk and Sweeney 18 year.
Nice nose. You get the sweet with smoothness and once you try it delicious. Very smooth. I get the smoky, candy floral notes. Very easy sipper.
Don pancho 8 yr
No real nose. Smooth. Fruity and spicy. I would give this closer to 8.5.
Master Reserve 21
Color is slightly lighter than 30 year and smells a little dulled but get similar notes and taste. Overall good rum
Original Spiced Gold
Good for purpose
Perfect with a coke. Great blend of traditional spiced rum that novice and experience rum drinkers should enjoy
Nice smell and reasonably priced. Sweet notes of candy most notably caramel with similar color. Smooth on rocks or with coke. Very good overall. I was
Reunion Single Cask
The nose is delicious like most plantation rums but it takes it to the next level. Very smooth with candy like qualities. Little bite. Enjoy on rocks
Another plantation hit
A little less on the nose than le reunion but doesn’t disappoint. The sweetness hits the tongue and is very smooth. Similar characteristics of reunion
XO 20th Anniversary (old bottle)
Another plantation hit
Along the lines of most plantation rums. Smooth with candy like notes but you get a nice toffee bouquet taste. Very smooth with no bitter or heat down
Nice smooth rum. Sweet notes like other plantation rums with sweet candy like notes and very smooth to the tongue and throughout.
Cool bottle and taste doesn’t disappoint.
I know captain gets a bad rap but consider its purpose. This version is very good. There is a hit of alcohol but doesn’t stay long. Initially you get
Good with coke
Nice sweetness with vanilla, banana qualities. Easy going mixer. Caramel notes for a decent priced rum and option from captain.
Ron Del Barrilito
Barrilito 3 star
Nice simple Carmel nose with no real alcohol bite. Has candy, caramel, banana flavor. Very good sipper
Maderis 5 plus 3
Smell is wonderful. Very smooth. I was hoping for more flavor but very good rum
1703 Master Select
Mount gay 1703
Typical high end run nose. Buttery, smooth sweetness with caramel and toffee notes. Enjoyed it.
Crystal clear in color and very little smell. Maker is right that this is smooth and honestly could be sipped but ideal in your classic drinks like a
Panama Single Cask Pineau des Charentes Finish
Nice compliment to plantation rums
Typical sweet nose and taste has a little bite of alcohol but minimal. The vanilla, toffee and caramel notes carry you through to a very enjoyable rum
Nice bacardi option
A little pricey but nose gives you nice banana and vanilla aroma. Relatively smooth with a little bit at end. Came off a little dull but overall decen
You get a fruity sweet note to the nose. You get a vanilla root beer smell to me. Definitely a mixer. I should have tried with root beer but overall g
3 Stars Artisanal
Sweet 3 Star plantation
Colorless with sweet smell. Pretty smooth on rocks with subtle sweetness. Overall ok. Probably best in a mixer. Goes fine with a coke. Would think fru
I didn’t get as much alcohol to nose as I read but think it’s always good to let breathe a bit. I get some alcohol to nose with charred barrel along w
I don’t get much to nose. Pretty smooth taste with wood, smoky, oak and I get sweetness from sugar. Good rum but have had better
Nose not bad for overproof. I put on ice and let it breathe. Not typical gasoline as expected and can be consumed as sipper but not recommended. Had C
A little alcohol bite to nose thou very smooth with banana notes mainly. Sweeter rum. Not bad
Rl seale 10 year
Ok smell. Not too strong. Smooth but no real distinctive notes.
Smooth nose and taste. Thou somewhat generic flavors
Ko lai spice
Nose is like a and w cream soda. Taste is a little sweet like vanilla icing with hint of spice. I GEt clove and similar spices. I would give this 6.5.
The Forgotten Cask
Chairmans forgotten cask
Funky nose. Caramel notes with spice. Pretty smooth.
Oak & Cane
Oak & cane
Gold rum. For a craft rum does have flavor. No real nose, little sweet. Can be used as supper neat or on rocks. It’s made with orange peel which must
Bacardi gran reserva limitada
First opening bottle you get a rubbing alcohol to nose. After letting breathe you get more of the sweetness. I get a creaminess, spice, peppery, orang
Better than it smells
I was nervous at first since it smelled like rubbing alcohol. The taste was light but really smooth with fruit and vanilla notes. You can sip it but n
Family Reserve Old
Initial smell is nice with sweet aroma but initial flavor misses but almost a second later you get a smooth, warming sensation of caramel sweetness th
Dried fruit dominates the nose. A little burn but overall smooth. Obviously a mixer rum but I like to try a taste or two neat. You definitely get the
Unique bottle. Not much nose other than alcohol. Flavor does exist. To me vanilla notes and nice bouquet
Nice amber color, nose is light with that sweet Carmel smell. It is sweet with a little burn but not bad. Nutty. Decent
Beer guys. Ok rum. You do get the nuttiness but not real powerful. Not much to the nose or palate. Just average thou not a lot of alcohol taste so tha
Estate Diamond Dark
Cruzan diamond dark 5 year
I let it breathe. You get the traditional sweet nose. Little bite but goes away and warms back up at end. I get the vanilla notes and oak from barrel.
John Emerald Gene's
John emerald spiced
Nose appears to be nutmeg and cinnamon. Taste is overly dominated by cinnamon. Predominantly a mixer. Good with coke. Probably would rate at 6. 6
Sweet nose. It’s fine. Came off as dessert rum but you definitely get rum
Maggie farm silver
I think it would go best with a mojito or similar type drink. I had it in an airport and had with coke. Different. Maybe too sweet so again why I thin
Sweet with banana as key flavor. I got some caramel. Probably ideal in frozen mixer. Not comparable to true sipper but still good.
Maderas 5 and 5
You get oak barrel and some alcohol. Relatively smooth thou not much flavor. Subtle caramel and candy notes. I actually like 5 and 3 better. Close to
El dorado 3 year
Had with fruit punch and mostly coke. Not a sipper. Nothing remarkable about it. It didn’t make drink worse just didn’t enhance it. Smooth for most pa
Flor de Cana
Extra Dry 4
Flor de Cana 4 year
Not much of a nose. White rum. As sipper, thou I wouldn’t think it’s intended for that has definite alcohol to tongue. Definitely better with coke or
Least favorite plantation rum
You definitely get a hit of strong alcohol that stays with you. It really dominates the taste. Good smell like other plantation rums with a nice sweet
Definitely a mixing rum. Tried on own actually smoother than expected. A little sweet smell. Taste isn’t complex as expected thou taste not as bad as
Sea Wynde 1.st Edition
Ok rum. Some smoothness but you get that hit of heat from alcohol. Not a ton of flavor. Not much nose
Black adder 17
You definitely get the alcohol to the nose. Stronger alcohol content than typical. I expected stronger alcohol heat but not as bad as nose thou tongue
The Real McCoy
Real McCoy 3 year
Clean nose. Honestly not much flavor but smooth with no burn. Definitely best for mixer.
I typically rate based on several factors. Compared to a top of line rum yes this would be a one or two. I feel this rum purpose is for a coke to be a
Nice nose considering it’s a mixer rum and relatively smooth with no real flavor. Again not created for sipper but with coke does balance well. For sm
Sweet smell but nothing remarkable. Agree not meant for sipper but tried and had a bit of bite with little flavor. Does mix fine with coke but nothing
St. Lucia Pot Still
Hamilton pot still
Smells like man working on road. Fortunately tastes better but nothing remarkable to me. In fairness I don’t care for agricole
Wicked dolphin spiced
I didn’t get much from nose. Maybe light caramel but mostly subtle alcohol. To get flavor I had to sip neat. Even ice diluted any flavor. Had with cok
Sweet nose with liquor hit to nose. Tried to sip and actually not bad from a strong alcohol aspect but sure it’s made for mixed drinks. Had with coke
Crystal clear color. You get a sweet aroma with lemon. Taste is decent with a non colored drink like sprite. Decent for an everyday rum if you like le
Chairman's The Forgotten Cask
11 months ago
Don Pancho 8-Year
11 months ago
Abuelo Gran Reserva 12-Year
11 months ago
Oak & Cane Artisan Gold
12 months ago
Flor de Cana Extra Dry 4
about 1 year ago
See more rum ratings