Posting your rating...
Black Magic Black Spiced rum

Black Magic Black Spiced

Caribbean | Aged

74 ratings
Tasty, but not quite great


Rate Black Magic Black Spiced

Tap to Rate
Click to Rate

Have an opinion about this rum?

Signup to rate this rum!

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove

74 Black Magic Black Spiced ratings

Sort by: Popularity | Date | Rating


Posted 25 days ago by Flark from Netherlands with 1 rating

Sweet and soft, nice bitters. Dark color, like cola. Soft in the throat. Bit like a "Kraken" but less sophisticated and flatter.


Posted 2 months ago by Chris Moulton from Canada with 15 ratings

Definitely a sipper. Too sweet for me to mix with soda . Drank it with sparkling water. Not terrible tasting just real sweet. Tastes like a vanilla rum.


Posted 6 months ago by toonstormm from United Kingdom with 30 ratings

What a surprise this one was! Found it in B&M for £17.99 so couldn’t refuse. Very Kraken-esque and at half the price. Lovely stuff!


Posted 6 months ago by Yatoss from United Kingdom with 29 ratings

If you like sweet spiced rums, then this one is very easy to drink and has lots of flavour


Posted 7 months ago by Vince11881 from United States with 28 ratings

Honestly I’d have to do a side by side to taste the difference, but this is essentially Kraken. A supposed black strap molasses rum, that is sweet, smooth and syrupy. However the artificial flavors of vanilla, and the obvious Carmel coloring and strong post-distillation sugar make me wonder how much of this magic is meant to cover up a mediocre rum at best. I’d assume that hangovers are in store for repeat offenders of this dark rum. I’ve definitely had worse but that’s not in any way a recommendation. Unless you’re looking for a sugar coma steer clear.


Posted 8 months ago by Mark Ellis from United Kingdom with 38 ratings

A good competitor to Kraken, very moorish, very reasonably priced


Posted 8 months ago by Lukestar122 from Canada with 25 ratings

Very similar to Kraken but even sweeter. Great mixer, nice flavor... so much sugar.

I'll stick to kraken I think.


Posted 8 months ago by PCMike from Dominican Republic with 8 ratings

I will admit that I am not a spiced rum drinker. I pick a bottle up in FLA. First impressions were that it was VERY sweet. I kind of abandoned the bottle. A few years later, I decided to try again. Not bad, but still too sweet for me. Vanilla is overwhelming as well. I think I will save this for some house party...somewhere.


Posted 9 months ago by scaifea from United Kingdom with 5 ratings

Neat with no ice.
Not a bad rum. Doesn't have the aroma of a rum to drink neat but tastewise it isn't too bad. Strong maple syrup/brown sugar aromas. Getting a nice cherry flavour from it and some pepper kicks around the mouth, but overall very smooth drinking.

Small 8e218b38 80c6 4e71 898d 1b1a7336c073

Posted 10 months ago by Knownot from New Zealand with 18 ratings

This is an incredibly easy to drink beverage.

Delicious flavour with quite a creamy experience. I oft compare it to a chocolatey liqueur. So if you know someone who like chocolate then they will be sure to enjoy this.

This will definitely be one I pick up again in the future.