Don't like to see ratings when mixing rum with cola or something else

Sign up or Log In to change notification settings.
jrtglobal avatar image
jrtglobal (PREMIUM) 🇪🇸 | 14 ratings Author Posted 15 Aug '23

I think it's a killer to uave rums rated whenever they are mixed. To really evaluate a rum it ahould be done without mixing. Obviously, lots of miss-ratings here. 

Mr. Rumantic avatar image
Mr. Rumantic 🇩🇪 | 286 ratings Replied 15 Aug '23

But if a rum is for mixing it is not fair to rate it when you drink it pure. The question is, do i have to rate Mixing Rums at all. Maybe they need there own place. I think it is ok to try a rum in different ways and add some notes like "works better in Coke, or with some ice" but it should not change the rating. As you said sipping rums should always get a rating while beeing drunk pure. 

Stefan Persson avatar image
Stefan Persson (PREMIUM) 🇸🇪 | 482 ratings Replied 15 Aug '23

My opinion is that all rum should be rated/reviewed tasted neat.

But a comment about about how it works mixed is of course very OK.

Andy avatar image
Andy (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 135 ratings Replied 23 Sep '23

I have really disliked a few rums aged between 5-10 years, and might not have even finished the bottle if only tasting neat. Then after a little cola (I like Pepsi Max personally), the mix tastes incredible. Should this rum then not get a little extra credit for it's ability to mix with cola?

BTW RR used to include an option to indicate how the tasting was done (eg straight, on ice, mixed), but I didn't know what to do with that extra data so I hid the field. May be worth reviving it someday...

Mr. Rumantic avatar image
Mr. Rumantic 🇩🇪 | 286 ratings Replied 23 Sep '23

No I think it should not get a little extra Credit because it would change the overall score even it is not drinkable without Coke. Tasting good in Coke is not something a rum should be proud of. Most high class rums taste better in Coke than cheap ones.  For example I had a 20y old Mount Gay in Coke. It was so good. Should they all get extra Credits now? And for me a spicy Rum tasts better in Coke than a fruity Rum. So do i give all spicy rums extra Credit for beeing spicy and therefore tasting better with Coke for me personally? I think Rum should only be judged neat. But appart from that i love some good rum & Coke. For me cuban rum is best for that. 

Mr. Rumantic avatar image
Mr. Rumantic 🇩🇪 | 286 ratings Replied 24 Sep '23

This is the disadvantage if there is only one text field for the evaluation. Otherwise you could, for example, tick "good for mixing" or "tastes better on ice" or something like that. Or you write something like "ad one point if you drink it in coke" 😅 

Andy avatar image
Andy (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 135 ratings Replied 24 Sep '23

It's a fair point that really old rum probably tastes great with cola as well. The challenge with any kind of tick box is taken to the extreme some users who really don't like a 20+ year might then say 'good for mixing' which would defeat the purpose. 

I guess the nice thing about the site is everyone uses a slightly different method of rating. A ratings sort for 'friends' was recently launched, so hopefully that pushes people to friend more users with similar rating methods and tastes and focus on those ratings. Stream also has a 'Friends' sort - so in theory someone could navigate the site to basically only see friend ratings and exclude those dastardly cola raters...

Paul B avatar image
Paul B 🇺🇸 | 470 ratings Replied 24 Sep '23

I have always rated my rums neat and have done side-by-side neat comparisons to separate a few rums in question. If a rum is a great neat sipper or works well OTR, then why waste it with cola?  I always have mentioned such details in my reviews. So the solution is simple: read the entire review!!! For those who only rate in simple smart phone sentences, I simply ignore those, but I respect their rating.

Cola is to rum as the Margarita is to tequila. Those drinks were created to hide the taste of bad spirits. Only one with money to burn would use a super premium tequila in their margaritas. The same goes for the rum and cola crowd. Why waste a $100 or more per bottle by disguising it with cola? Notice that I do not use the term Coke, because I prefer Pepsi.

I also have my own classification called Gold Mixers. None of them are recommended for repeat purchases.

Paul B avatar image
Paul B 🇺🇸 | 470 ratings Replied 24 Sep '23

I have one very unique "mixer rum" that is always on hand. It is Cana Fuerte 7-Year from Nicaragua.. It is made from cane juice instead of molasses. It mixes well with anything and it costs less than $20 US per bottle. It can also be enjoyed OTR, but never neat. It is not a Gold Mixer. Because of the sugar cane juice as the base, I cannot call it aged. So I have it classified as an Agricole, despite it having no similarities to true agricoles from the French West Indies. This one is truly in a class by itself. However, it's older brother aged 16 years is indeed a neat sipper. It's younger brother aged 4 years is not even worth buying.

Andy avatar image
Andy (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 135 ratings Replied 25 Sep '23

I always have a bottle of Plantation 5-Year on hand for a good rum and cola is someone should want one - it's a little pricier than $20 but mixes really well with cola.

Rumrun11 avatar image
Rumrun11 (PREMIUM) 🇺🇸 | 125 ratings Replied 4 Oct '23

Kind of a grey area as what someone may consider a mixer others can absolutely consider a sipper. I am not sure how someone though can accurately rate a rum based solely on tasting as a mixer and not neat or on the rocks. 

bar la moura avatar image
bar la moura 🇭🇷 | 152 ratings Replied 31 Oct '23

usually light rum is made for mixing, even special ones (veritas/probita) are light and they are not for sipping but for mixing

another category is rum liquor that have 10% or more of sugar, you can sip it with some ice ... but they can also go in some cocktails ...

i see a lot of light rums and rum liquors in this site, so when i write a review i can give high rating but  never forget what for these products are designed ... of course an aged rum is for sipping and very different thing !