Posting your rating...
« Back to Posts

Looking for a go to.


Sign up or Log In to change notification settings.
Ffffff

Jg33

Posted 20 Nov '20 from United States with 0 ratings

Hey everyone, I’ve recently really gotten into rum, and I’m looking for. A go to rum under the 50$ mark. (Preferably lower than that). Right now I have Kirk and Sweeney 12 to try out as well as the diplomatic preserves exclusiva. What are some suggestions?

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 239 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

You can follow Capn Jimbos recommendation to build a basic reference collection.
http://rumproject.com/menuitem5.html

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 347 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Jg33:

Here are my top 20 best buy rums. Notice that most of them are dry or semi-dry with a few overproofs where water or ice can be added to your liking. Since almost everyone starts off with the most popular rum on this site, I must mention that DRE is a sugar bomb with 41 grams per liter (gpl) of added sugar. As for Kirk & Sweeney, their 12 Year was one of the first ones that I tried from them and I wound up hating it. Stick with their 18 Year, which I have ranked as 32 out of 346 in my best buy rums.. So here goes it with my list.

Blackwell's Reserve
Plantation OFTD 138 Overproof
South Bay Small Batch (if found)
Dictador 12
Clarin Le Rocher (if found)
Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaican 100 Overproof
El Dorado 8
Pusser's Gunpowder Proof 109 Overproof
Plantation Original Dark Double Aged
Depaz Blue Cane Amber Rhum (if found)
Carta Vieja 8 Anos
Ron Cartavio Solera 12
Ron Alegro XO
Vizcaya VXOP 21 (sweet)
Matusalem Gran Reserva 18
Santa Teresa 1796
Angostura 1919
Carta Vieja Golden Cask 18
Doorly's XO
Foursquare Spiced

I hope this helps. I saved you an awful lot of research on this site.

Ffffff

Falcon91Wolvrn03 (PREMIUM)

From United States with 447 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

For under $50 I would recommend the Centenario 20-Year. It's a bit sweet, but I like rums that way. :-)

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 347 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Falcon:

Good to see you back in the discussions! Jg33 would probably like your sugar bomb recommendation that has 40 gpl of added sugar. However, for me, I have that one ranked in my lower 36% of my best buy rums. My order of favorites from Ron Centenario is the 9 year Commerativo, followed closely by their 12 year. Their 7 year trails quite a bit and their 20 Year qualifies for me to never buy again. That experience was so bad that I refuse to try their 25 year or 30 year.

I did like all rum newbies and started out with very sweet rums. I had a rather large and proud collection to start with. Then after only two months, almost all of those sweetened rums changed flavors for the worse. Heavily sweetened rums do not last in the bottle! The added sugar also wreaked havoc on my internal plumbing. For those two reasons, I have now avoided overly sweetened rums like the plague. The only sweet repeat purchase rums for me are now Plantation XO 20th Anniversary and Vizcaya VXOP 21. If I run across the sugar bomb of Dos Maderas 5x5, I will also gladly buy that one.

Ffffff

Stefan Persson (PREMIUM)

From Sweden with 164 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

My preferred “go to” which is also my “best value for money” costs between 19 and 23 € at European online shops. They are English Harbour 5yo, Chairman’s Reserve and Appleton 12yo.
If you want something sweeter I suggest El Dorado 12yo or 15 yo.
From Barbados it’s possible to find quite many. The cost is a little bit higher, but still below your limit. They are Cockspur 12yo, Doorly’s XO and 12yo, Sixty Six 12yo and R.L. Seales
Picture: My three Go To

Ffffff

Pirate

From Greece with 23 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Why not go with the basics?

Seale 10yr
Appleton 12yr
Doorly's 12 or XO

Ffffff

Falcon91Wolvrn03 (PREMIUM)

From United States with 447 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Thanks Paul!

I realize you don't like the sweeter rums as much as I do, but I'll disagree that people will move from sweet to dry rums as they become more experienced. I know a large number of experienced drinkers that still prefer sweet rums to dry rums. It's kind of like telling people they'll grow out of Frosted Flakes and move to Corn Flakes. Sure, maybe some people do, but certainly not everyone.

I definitely agree with what you've said before in that people have different tastes, and you should try to find reviewers with similar tastes as your own to help find new rums, rather than just looking at a rum's overall score.

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 347 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Falcon:

I had to switch from sweet rums to dry rums out of necessity for those two reasons mentioned earlier. At first, I hated having to do this. Then as I got used to dry rums and being able to add anything that I wanted to them, I could no longer appreciate those original sugar bomb favorites. Now I restrict myself to rums with no more than 28 gpl of added sugar, with Dos Maderas 5x5 being the only one to have more than that with 36 gpl of added sugar. I love sweet rums, but they just don't love me. And as I once told everyone in my wine drinking days, if it does a number on your system the next day, then it is not a good wine no matter how many points it has earned.

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 367 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Hey guys, that’s the cool thing about rum. The amazing range you can choose from for your rum journey. From sweet to dry, week to strong, bland to high ester. I prefer all kind of rum, witch depends on mood and season.
I recommend as a to go rum under 50.-, the Malteco Triple 1, it's also a smooth high proof rum for beginners.
Don't forget the Plantation O.F.T.D.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 239 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Plantation OFTD could kill some inexperienced beginners :)
Better to start with three Maltecos.

Ffffff

Falcon91Wolvrn03 (PREMIUM)

From United States with 447 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

@Paul - Sorry to hear why you had to move away from sweet rums. My best friend has the same rum taste as me (he's not a rumratings member), and his doctor recently told him he can't drink any sugar based alcohol drinks or drinks with sugar in them. He's pretty bummed, but getting used to whiskey now instead.

@Rene - Yes, the range of rums is simply amazing. Sampling the many different styles is a big part of the fun of rum tasting. :-)

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 367 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

OFTD for sure for Tiki-drinks ! I love it neat but use it most for Cuba Libre.
WARNING for Beginners: Never drink OFTD neat ! ;-)

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 347 ratings Replied 20 Nov '20

Falcon:

I visit my doctor every 4-6 months after a blood test. The results of my blood test always keep improving and I am no longer a diabetic after about 30 years. I just smile and tell myself that rum is gluten free and stay away from all added sugars. One cannot tell doctors too much these days because they will try to impose their religious views upon their patients. I am smart enough to catch these episodes and find another doctor..

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove