Posting your rating...
« Back to Posts

What other agricole rums will i like?


Sign up or Log In to change notification settings.
Ffffff

Pirate

Posted 2 Nov '20 from Greece with 23 ratings

I very recently fetched myself a bottle of Rhum J.M. XO and am completely enamored with it! I already cast a glimpse upon that other discussion, for "rums with no sugar added" and noticed the agricole post... But i thought to ask about specifically. Would prefer aged stuff, as well as premium and noteworthy, but i wouldn't say no to more common entries, provided that they are great sport...

So, just recommend to me a special agricole bottle that will set me up nicely, please! After all, variety is the spice of life! No sugar, unadultered, preferrably old, special bottle (not limited release)!

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 239 ratings Replied 2 Nov '20

https://www.limited-rum.de/epages/79492923.mobile/de_DE/?ObjectPath=/Shops/79492923/Products/DAMA1995
https://thefatrumpirate.com/damoiseau-rhum-vieux-millesime-1995
Try this one, it's old and still not expensive IMHO but watch out it's cask strength.
Some other recommendations would be in the >125€ price range if they are of interest to you.

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 367 ratings Replied 2 Nov '20

Hi Pirate

J.M. XO, a great start into the world of Agricole. Enjoy it !
My recommendations:
- Rhum JM Calvados Cask Finish
- Chamarel XO
- Riviere du Mat Opus5
- Bielle 2003 Brut de Fut 8-Year
- Neisson L'Espirit of Neisson 70
- Clairin
- Rhum Courcelles VX 1972 Brut de Fût, Edition 2014

And yes, as you say: "variety is the spice of life!"

Ffffff

Stefan Persson (PREMIUM)

From Sweden with 164 ratings Replied 3 Nov '20

Hi Pirate!
As Rene wrote is the J.M XO an excellent entry to to the Agricole world.
Another Martinique Rhum that can compete with that one is La Mauny XO.
Some other Martinique Rhum I can recommend is:
Depaz Cuvée Prestige
Depaz Grande Réserve XO (White label)
HSE XO
J.M 1845
St James 12yo
St James l’Essential
From Marie Galante I can recommend Bielle from where I so far have tasted the best white Agricole, Bielle 59. Another one from MG is the brand Habitation Bellevue’s 1821 series. My bottles of that one is still unopened, but after what I’ve heard it should be great.
From Guadeloupe, which is my favorite Agricole district, I can recommend everything from the brands Montebello and ReimonenQ and besides them I can recommend Bologne XO and Longueteau XO.
Picture: Some of the recommended.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 239 ratings Replied 12 Nov '20

If you want to invest a little bit, there's a new release from Savanna, wild islands.
They produce a very good quality rhums for connoisseurs.
They have very strong, intensive rhums with crazy flavors in their product range.
https://www.rumundco.de/navi.php?qs=savanna+twie

Ffffff

Pirate

From Greece with 23 ratings Replied 12 Nov '20

Wow, many interesting suggestions! My budget is a little low right now, so i got caught up in a tight spot. Also, local retailers have very few of those brands; from my last visit in the most diverse store of the city, it had only Clement, Saint James and J.M.

Speaking of which, is Saint James 15 a good choice? Stefan here suggested the "12" and the "essential" and i remember seeing 15 in one of those lists, of the "best 10/20 of 2020" type... Is Clement XO good? Are the J.M. Cuvee de Fondateur and J.M. cuvee 1845 worth the price and effort to get?

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 239 ratings Replied 12 Nov '20

There are some reviews for those rhums. I think all three are not bad, but I would prefer cask strength if I would spend >100€.
http://thelonecaner.com/r0294/
http://thelonecaner.com/r0725/
https://therumbarrel.co.uk/2019/11/20/clement-rhum-vieux-agricole-xo/

Ffffff

martin jeppesen

From Denmark with 241 ratings Replied 13 Nov '20

Pirate.

As vomi says they all reccomendable but of those three I would personally choose Saint james 15. Unfortunately it have had a bit of a price bump the past years. But it’s very tasty.

Ffffff

The Rum Barrel

From United Kingdom with 0 ratings Replied 13 Nov '20

Damoiseau 5 Year Old from Guadeloupe is an absolute beauty.

Ffffff

Stefan Persson (PREMIUM)

From Sweden with 164 ratings Replied 13 Nov '20

About Saint James 12 or 15, I would say the 12 is smoother and a better value for money.
Saint James l’Essential, J.M Cuvée 1845 & Clement XO (the old bottle with the extra ordinary blend, see picture) are all three excellent Agricole. The Saint James is more or less for sale every week at Catawiki with a possibility to get a better price.

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove