Posting your rating...
« Back to Posts

Your favorite Navy style rum


Sign up or Log In to change notification settings.
Ffffff

vomi1011

Posted 17 Sep '20 from Germany with 216 ratings

I wonder what is you favorite navy style rum.
Except for my own blend my favorite is Silver Seal Old Navy Rum. It's a very balanced, still heavy and fruity rum.

What I have tasted so far:
Kill Devil Navy Style
Plantation OFTD
Eight Islands Dark Carribean rum
Velier Royal Navy Style rum
Black Tot 5y

I wanna share also my receipt for my favorite navy style rum:
Mix a woody rum (Flor de Cana 18 or Mount Gay XO) 2/1 with Cross&Smith (Hampden).
A woody rum goes very well with a fruity one.
Add a shot of RA Demerara 2004 53.7% (or ELD21). Let the blend breath for 30min and enjoy.
If you have some drops of Caroni left, add them to your 4cl glas.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

"Velier Royal Navy Style rum" is more a Caroni than a navy blend :)
Maybe there will be some evaporation and the blend will change.

Ffffff

Charles M

From United Kingdom with 132 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

Does Pusser's 15yo, which goes down very nicely, count?

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

Sure, if it's you favorite.

There was also a good edition in gunpowder proof. It's still available but hard to find for a good price.
https://thefatrumpirate.com/pussers-rum-50th-anniversary-rum

Ffffff

Charles M

From United Kingdom with 132 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

I had a lot of flagons from the last batch the Royal Navy had. Moved most of them on, but did decant one into 6 and a bit bottles @ about 54.3%. TBH it's a pretty good drop.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

You mean this one:
https://www.whiskyauctioneer.com/lot/156157/royal-navy-imperial-rum-flagon-1-gallon

Yes, it's the original Navy Rum. I'm thinking about to buy a bottle. But the price is heavy.
https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/12109/black-tot-last-consignment-royal-naval-rum

Ffffff

Charles M

From United Kingdom with 132 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

Isn't that a marvellous coincidence that my flagon is the same ABV as Black Tot !!!!

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

Black tot last consignment contains probably the same rum as your flagon.
They just filled this rum in bottles as you have done.

"About all you know going in is that it come from British Royal Navy stocks left over after the final rum ration was issued to the Jolly Jack Tars on Black Tot Day and that it was released in 2010 on the same day."
"According to lore, it supposedly contains rums from Barbados, Guyana (of course), Trinidad and a little Jamaica".
http://thelonecaner.com/r0237/

I don't know how it tastes, but I think my own blend goes also in that direction.

Ffffff

Charles M

From United Kingdom with 132 ratings Replied 18 Sep '20

No probably about it.

Ffffff

Immiketoo (PREMIUM)

From Greece with 37 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

I have yet to buy a Navy rum, unless you count OTFD.

I do have quite a few high proof Foursquare expressions but I’m not sure those count as Navy rum.

Pussers is on my list to try.

Ffffff

Docsarvis (PREMIUM)

From United States with 146 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

I love Navy rum. For me it’s Pussers. The regular British Navy is the standard. Really great stuff. Pussers 15 also good, arguably a tiny bit more complex, but at literally 3 times the price of the regular, just not worth it.
Followed by Austrian Empire Navy Rum. Very good!

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

I'm going to try Pussers Gunpowder in some weeks.
I just tried the best navy style rum I ever had: Velier Tiger Shark.

Of course it's not cheap, but it's fantastic.
I love Demerara flavors in combination with Worthy Park.

Ffffff

DFW.TX

From United States with 24 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

"I just tried the best navy style rum I ever had: Velier Tiger Shark"

DAMN! Damn damn damn!!! I wish Luca would import this and the Royal Navy VOR to the States. Just looking at the bottle makes my mouth water. ;)

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

I was inspired by the WP in the Velier navy style rum. I created a new great blend.

2 Mount Gay XO
1 Velier Forsyths WPM 2006
1 Artesanal Diamond 2004 (you can also try ElD21)
A hint of WPE 2019 SBS (high ester Worthy Park) to get more fruity notes

It's Guyana and WP driven and also very tasty.

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 361 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

Oh, yes definitely Silver Seal old Navy Rum, a dream of a Navy Rum, wish I had bought a few more bottles.

-Gunroom
-Pusser's Gunpowder Proof
-O.F.T.D.

nice too

@vomi1011
"If you have some drops of Caroni left, add them to your 4cl glass."
I’m sure it's a joke, you mixing with caroni ???
Drops of Caroni are like gold - my absolute rum love ! :-)

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

Not all Caroni are great. I have some bottles that are not very good. Sometimes I use a little bit of them for this blend.
Luka (Velier) used also some casks for his old navy blend. I'm sure they weren't the best.

The Worthy Park WPM Forsyth 2006 and 2019 WPE are worth the same as my Caronis. I use them sometimes also for mixing because the navy blend tastes better for me than each one of them.

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 361 ratings Replied 26 Sep '20

Ok. not all Caroni are great or I say not all are so intense like others. I prefer the dirty ones like the Velier, specially the 12 yo with diesel, petrol and burned rubber aromas. But I also like woody ones like Rum Nation or Berry's with fresh chopped wood and wet moss aromas.
Funny your mixing thing, I just thought about today while the Mezan Jamaica rating how would it taste paired with the Guianas Mezan. Cool, keep on mixing/blend !!! If the result is satisfying.

Ffffff

Stefan Persson (PREMIUM)

From Sweden with 163 ratings Replied 27 Sep '20

My experience of "Navy rooms" is very limited. The only one in my rumbar is “Pusser's 15yo Nelson's blood” in the old bottle with the red label and I like it a lot.
So after following this discussion I have to try to find some suitable "Navy rums" to test.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 1 Oct '20

I just rated Pussers Gunpowder proof.
And I was surprised how good it is. It has the largest proportion of Guyana rum in a navy blend that I know. That's why it's so tasty for me.
If I were a navy soldier I would drink that the whole day.
It's not as fruity as the Velier Tiger Shark but I like it's dark molasses based taste.

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 337 ratings Replied 1 Oct '20

Pusser's Gunpowder Proof is ranked in the upper 5.7% of all the rums that I have reviewed up to this point. As an added bonus, it is relatively cheap. It is a "rebuy" for me IF I can find another bottle.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 1 Oct '20

Yeah, I'm going to buy at least three bottles of this one.
I would love to try the old one from Barbados/Guyana/Trinidad but I think the current one is better.
Jamaica + Guyana, what could be better :)

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 337 ratings Replied 2 Oct '20

vomi1011:

To put it into perspective, you could buy 7 bottles of this Pusser's Gunpowder Proof for less than the price of one bottle of Diplomatico Ambassador. The price of a rum does not always equate to how good it really is, which is why my limit is $120 maximum per bottle. Nothing worse than spending a lot on a rum only to find out that cheaper ones taste much better.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 9 Oct '20

Get ready the new black tot 50th Anniversary will be available in NOVEMBER 2020
https://blacktot.com/our-rums/black-tot-50th-anniversary/
Some more informations about it:
https://cocktailwonk.com/2020/07/untangling-modern-navy-rums.html

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 361 ratings Replied 9 Oct '20

Poa, surely an outstanding and hyper-delicious rum, but worth the price ?
If you can afford it, so why not.
Unfortunately, I'm not a manager, bank director or otherwise wealthy. :-)
But a very interesting story.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 9 Oct '20

I think it will be in the 80-150€ range, like Velier blends. They choosed good rums for this navy blend.

"Black Tot 50th Anniversary Rum: A custom blend, quite different than Elixir’s normal Black Tot blend. The label has been hailed as a model of transparency, listing every component rum and its percentage in the blend. This rum is bottled at navy issuing strength: 54.5% ABV. It will be available in the U.S. It will undoubtedly be more than $50."

Ffffff

Rene Rum

From Switzerland with 361 ratings Replied 9 Oct '20

That would be nice in this price range, I think it's far more.
But yes, surprise, surprise.

Ffffff

Paul B (PREMIUM)

From United States with 337 ratings Replied 10 Oct '20

vomi1011:

Thanks for the two excellent articles on Black Tot Rums and the confusion that often goes along with them. The last article mentioned that Pusser's Blue Label became available in 2010. Sorry, but this is clearly wrong! I have been buying Pusser's Blue Label off and on since the late eighties. Maybe they meant that the new company took over in 2010. I have since migrated to their Gunpowder Proof IF I can find any more bottles. As for their overly sugared 15 Year, I am glad that it is now gone from their lineup (or modified in a different bottle)..

I think that the allure of sampling true Black Tot has a lot to do with history and not the taste of the rum. At $1000 per bottle for the original, they can keep it! Also, there is some dispute as to where the original actually wound up, so buyer beware!

The 50th Anniversary Black Tot does indeed look like a premium blended rum, even though it has only 0.6% of the "original" version. However, if anyone truly believes that the British Navy went out of their way to blend such a complex rum for their sailor's daily rations, then I have a steamboat to sell them in the middle of the desert! Their daily rations were probably only a step above Bacardi.

If it becomes available for $120 US or less in November AND I can get a hold of a bottle of Pusser's Gunpowder Proof, I will gladly buy both and do a taste test side by side test for this site. However, I am already thinking that fools and their money will soon part, so this is all nothing but a marketing scheme.

Ffffff

Charles M

From United Kingdom with 132 ratings Replied 12 Oct '20

So Black Tot 50th Anniversary is a 9yo rum. I guess that it's quite clever that they list the breakdown of the blend, as well as being quite interesting. But no one has ever accused Raj and Sukhinder of not being very clever.

Ffffff

vomi1011

From Germany with 216 ratings Replied 12 Oct '20

The Velier Tiger Shark is 14 years old compared to this one. So I hope it will be released below the price of € 100.
Their black tot blend is not bad for just a 5y old rum. I would prefer more Demerara rum in the taste, but it did pretty well against the twice as expensive Silver Seal Old Navy rum.
The nice thing about the 50th Anniversary is the proportion of Demerara rum of 63%
and that's mostly the old rum.
If I would blend a navy rum I would also use Demerara rum in 2/3 proportion. That's why I'm very interested in this rum.

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove