Posting your rating...
« Back to Posts

How to find good rums for cheap

Sign up or Log In to change notification settings.


Posted 8 Aug '20 from United States with 337 ratings

This is mainly for the college crowd who wants to move on from Captain Morgan, Bacardi, and Sailor Jerry. All of these rums cost less than $25 US and all of these top ten cheap rums rank in my upper 20%. This was no easy task, so enjoy. The first one on this list rates as an 8 and the rest rate as a 7.

Blackwell's Reserve
El Dorado 8
Carta Vieja 8 Anos
896 8 Year
Doorly's XO
Selvarey White
Cana Brava 3 Year Old
Plantation Artisinal 3-Stars
Plantation Original Dark Double Aged
Foursquare Spiced



From United States with 337 ratings Replied 8 Aug '20

And conversely, here are my recommendations for worst buy rums costing more than $50 US, going from my rating of 6 all the way down to a 4.

Carupano 21 Year
Zacapa Edicion Negra
Avua Cachaca Tapinhoa
Foursquare 2004 Single Blend 11 Year
Don Q Gran Anejo
Diplomatico Vintage 2004
Avua Cachaca Jequitiba
Clement 10 Year
Gosling's Family Reserve Old



From United States with 24 ratings Replied 8 Aug '20

Ok, I'll play. For $20-$30 I'd recommend:

TW (Total Wine) exclusives....

Doorly's 8 yr ($19.99, have seen it on sale as low as $16.99. Hard to beat at $17)

RL Seale's 10 yr ($25.99, have seen it on sale for as low as $19.99. Recommended for the student who thinks Jack Daniels is top shelf stuff. A great party trick... when you're all sitting there passing around a J, tell your friends you left the bottle in the sun and it melted. Duuuuuuuude nooo waaaay)

Doorly's 12 yr ($26.99, have seen it on sale for as low as $23.99. For those college kids who want a 'sophisticated' pour. Recommended neat, of course. If you must... ok... an ice ball... nothing more. Afterall, you're a college student and we're trying to develop your palate. We don't want to send you out in the world mixing everything with coke)

Also in the price range at other fine liquor stores.....

Blackwell Fine Jamaican ($20.49. This one is pretty ok. It's versatile. NOT funky like other Jamaicans. Won't knock your socks off but solid at the price)

Hamilton 86 ($21.99. My 1st true love in the rum world. Started me on my path. A+- for what it is at the price. Would be my 2nd place recommendation behind Doorly's 12)

The Scarlet Ibis (an absolute sleeper at $23.67. Liquid bubble gum. Haven't tried it in cocktails yet but was originally made for Death & Co for such. This is a solid sipper, even at 98 proof)

Hamilton White 'Stache ($24.62 for a liter. A solid white. A liter?!! 25?!! I'm a college student, hell yeah, I'm all over it)

Hamilton 151 ($26.99... I would've gotten my money's worth from this if it was around when I was in college! This is the leader in the clubhouse when it comes to bang for buck. Throw that shit in Coke, I don't care)

If you want to spend closer to $30....

Plantation OFTD ($26.99 for a liter. Doesn't drink at all like something 138 proof)

Rum Fire ($29.25. What college student wouldn't want a solid, FUNKY overproof Jamaican?!? I would've thrown that in some Hawaiian Punch or ginger ale and got lit if it was around in my day)

I don't think Cana Brava is being produced anymore, but if you see it... buy buy buy! I've bought it as low as $12.49 but it was normally priced at $20.99. We have a good bit bunkered in case it's true about being discontinued.



From Czech Republic with 30 ratings Replied 8 Aug '20

First and foremost - Appleton 12y (Rare Blend) - should cost from 20-30 Euro.

Anything from Doorly's line you can afford
Wood's Navy Rum
Pusser's Navy Rum (Gunpowder blend)
Havana Club 3y (white), Havana Club 7y (dark) - the Cuban originals, stay away from Bacardi swill
Mount Gay XO, if you want to feel posh



From Germany with 208 ratings Replied 9 Aug '20

IMHO the very best one and cheapest is the Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaica Rum 0,7l 57%.
Because it's a classic navy style rum.
Very strong and intensive with 57%.
Great flavours and very well balanced.
And so damn cheap and delicious to sip that I can't believe it.



From United States with 337 ratings Replied 9 Aug '20

After the top 10 that I first posted, here is the next group of good cheap rums.

Brinley Gold Shipwreck Spiced
Vizcaya Cristal
Doorly's White
Diplomatico Planas
Havana Club 7
Alleyene Arthurs Special Barbados Rum
Don Q 151
Ron Centenario 9 Commemorativo
Flor de Cana 5 Anejo
Don Q Anejo
Ron Pontalba Dark
Ron Medellin 8
Flor de Cana 7
Brinley Gold Shipwreck Coconut
Clement Mahina Coco
Cruzan Hurricane Proof 137
Brinley Gold Shipwreck Mango
Barbancourt Pango
Doorly's 8 Year
Doorly's 5 Year
El Dorado Spiced


Docsarvis (PREMIUM)

From United States with 145 ratings Replied 18 Aug '20

Great conversation. Here are 2 that I have found:
-RWS Distillery, Lafayette Louisiana USA. This is genuinely very good small batch craft rum for only $22. USD
- For the cost of $12-$15 USD I like Cruzan Blackstrap.

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove