Thanks so much for submitting a report. It has been emailed to the Rum Captain and will be actioned shortly.
This Will look awesome on your rum shelf. Unfortunately the content is nothing out of the ordinary. A dry rum with AOK AS the dominating flavour - a flavour which doesn't evolve much or last very long.
Had to hide my disappointment from the rep. I just love Panamanian rums. This though seemed to be a rushed product. Aroma was fine. Come was a bit lighter than expected. Flavor was murder to its review. It just seemed like a it's trying too hard. Not that it burned, it just fell totally flat on the palate. Tickled my nose a little too, but that might be from it being closed too long and I got hit by that lingering alcohol vapor.
I returned to a favorite liquor store to stock up on more of the Carta Vieja 8 Anos rum. It is an almost perfect balance of wood and natural sweetness, with a low cost to boot. So I plunked down $50 US for this bottle, knowing very well that it is an 18 Year Solera rum.
Side by side in Glencairn glasses, both rums are similar except that this one has more flavors and smooths out the few remaining harsh edges found in the 8 year. As usual, I let each new rum breathe before sipping it to rate it. It came in very high in my overall rankings and deserves my rating of a 9. This was money well spent!
It has also edged out my Plantation XO 20th Anniversary in a side by side taste test. No easy feat, but I happen to like the very well represented flavors of wood and leather on this one. The Plantation XO rum has 24 gpl of added sugar and this Carta Vieja Golden Cask has only 7 gpl of added sugar. I am sure that this played a factor into my final judgment.
Warning on poor design of bottle!!!! After only 6 days from first opening it, the extremely tight fitting cork caused the thin glass just outside of the neck to break when corking it back up!!! Luckily, I have many choices of old bottles with real corks that I use for making pre-mixed batches of drinks. Somehow, no amount of glass fell into this rum, but I transferred it to an empty bottle of Ron Zacapa XO. If you do buy this rum, I strongly advise that the first thing that you do with it is transfer it to a much stronger bottle or replace the tight fitting cork. This will not stop me from buying this rum again nor will it lower my rating, but I also will not go out of my way again to find it once this one is all gone. It has taken me a year to find this rum that I rank as third out of 192 that I have tried. It also wound up in a bottle that costs twice as much and which that old rum ranked 11 notches lower.
Update August 10. 2019: I finally found another bottle of this great rum and had several premium empty bottles stashed away to transfer the contents to if needed. To my pleasant surprise, the cork has been redesigned from extremely tight fitting to almost perfect. This means that the top of the bottle now has much less chance of breaking when corking it back up. Either the company read my reviews or someone sued them. Whatever, I am thankful for the improvement in cork design and this rum still tastes great!
Fruity whisky masking itself as rum. For whisky lovers out there.
This rum starts out very nice when you see the unique decanteresque bottle. However, the rum is not as pleasing as the glass looks to the eye. The solera method and the 18 year is kind of misleading because you are led to believe that this is a rum aged for 18 years and thus must be very complex and superb in quality.
Unfortunately, this Panamanian rum doesn’t achieve those superlatives. Oak, vanilla, baking spices some dried fruit and somewhat drier than other Carta Vieja offerings.
Yes, this can be sipped neat or mixed, it’s just for the price, their are other go to rums that are better suited and of higher quality and taste to be enjoyed.
I had expectations being that it's an 18 year blend but alas, this fell hard off the cliff.. it feels like it's trying to be something else but failing at that. In the 18 range I'm expecting different flavors or lack there of with body or something to get me excited. Nope this shit taste like smoked leather boots, like old boots at that. It's to much like a rye bourbon mixed with hopes and dreams of being apart of a comic book or a school star jockey.
Una selección fantástica un balance único entre solera y experiencia en boca fuerte en nariz explosión de frutos rojos secos el decanter maravilloso Buen precio
Buen ron, aunque no colmo expectativas considerando precio y presentación. Buen color caramel intenso. Aroma y sabor algo fuerte. Para beber con algún hielo.
My expectations were much higher than this rum could provide.
Carta Vieja Rum Golden Cask is the "True" taste of Panama. The rum is smooth and refreshing. It is like an ocean breeze on a clear summer evening.
Love Carta Vieja rum I was expecting a lot more from this one. A little to dry for me still a good rum but to me it needs more body. Very oaky to me nice bottle but not worth the price.
I was expecting more from this rum for the price. It still is quite good rum. I do not understand some of the low ratings but to each his own I guess. Sure, if you were expecting a typical sweeter Panamanian rum you're going to be disappointed but let's look at it for what it is, not what we wish it to be.
It is a drier rum than typical Panamanian rum but not too dry. Although the oakiness is quite predominate giving it somewhat of a bite, there still is some sweetness with hints of vanilla and caramel. For those who like bourbon, this might be a good rum for them since this rum does have similarities to bourbon. Personally I rather use it in Coke Zero. I do believe this would be an excellent rum in various mixed drinks especially fruit-based and coffee-based drinks.