Posting your rating...
John Watling's Buena Vista rum

Rate John Watling's Buena Vista

Tap to Rate
Click to Rate

Have an opinion about this rum?

Signup to rate this rum!

14 John Watling's Buena Vista ratings

Sort by: Popularity | Date | Rating

Posted over 2 years ago by Russ from United States with 85 ratings

Nose: Rubbing alcohol and a charred barrel
Pallet: Undeveloped and harsh, a sad and unsuccessful attempt at being a decent rum
Finish: Gasoline, some spice, a little table sugar, and a charred barrel

This is the "best rum" Watling's offers and its best used in a frozen drink. This is a $12 rum that's nicely packaged and sold for $40+

I was tempted to give it a 3 Rating but I was overwhelmed with disappointment. The government of Nassau should shut this place down. It's a national embarrassment!

Posted about 3 years ago by Michael Regular from Canada with 36 ratings

While cruising we decided to find our way to the Waitling's distillery. Decided to try the selection at the bar. This was the better of the three offered. The taste/after taste was a bit overwhelming. Left without purchasing any, thought it overpriced.

Posted over 3 years ago by Jason from United States with 47 ratings

The caramelized flavors certainly come through, but not overbearingly so. Nicely balanced and solid enough to be sipped, although not as complex as others I've had. My favorite of their three offerings.

Posted 7 months ago by sebastiana from United States with 2 ratings

Overall great rum. Tour was amazing in the beautiful Buena Visita estate.

Posted 7 months ago by Mikenedham from United Kingdom with 15 ratings

Bought as present from bahamas - light in the mouth, oaky plenty of caramel but found it better in a strong dark &stormy than as a sipper

Posted 7 months ago by Scott Nowicki from United States with 5 ratings

Picked this baby up on Exuma. Subtle caramel flavor. Well balanced. Easy sipping gem. And a nice looking bottle to boot!

Posted 10 months ago by Phil from United States with 5 ratings

Just a really good sipping rum, not too harsh like some of the lower priced John Watling runs. Great with a cigar!

Posted over 2 years ago by Mike from United States with 2 ratings

Very beautiful color. Smooth start and finish. Not a mixing rum. Sip from glass neat or on rocks.

Posted over 2 years ago by Arthur from France with 1 rating

My friend make me a gift with this rum, and it was a nice smooth. Thanks John

Posted almost 3 years ago by Joola69 from United States with 2555 ratings

Visited Nassau last year with a colleague of mine and we wondered to the John Watling's Distillery by accident. It is the only distillery in Nassau and the distillery tour itself is definitely worth the effort. At the end of the tour there is a tasting of their 3 main rums and the Single Barrel for a tiny extra fee. The Buena Vista rum sits just below the Single Barrel rum, but I was not convinced on the flavors at all. Very harsh aged rum and a nasty burn at the end.

Posted almost 3 years ago by Beukeboom from United States with 305 ratings

After 30 years, my wife and I had enough money to actually go on a REAL vacation and decided to fly to the Bahamas. We stayed at Atlantis (which was a nightmare). All the best things were away from the "resort" and in and around Nassau. One of which was a tour of the John Watling's distillery. At the end of the tour my wife and I partook of the tasting of the three rums (and for an extra fee of only a couple of dollars they added their limited edition Single Barrel). Of the four, I liked the Buena Vista rum the best. I REALLY liked it.

First off, the rum's aroma is fantastic. Now as I has admitted many times before, I have no talent on picking up subtleties in aromas. I can tell you if I like it or not and if there is something distinctive in the aroma. The Buena Vista rum just has a wonderful aroma.

It is a rich, deep amber color.

I feel the flavor is excellent. Hints of vanilla and butterscotch with a touch of pepperiness. Also there is a bit of an oakiness about it as well. Very smooth. I do not detect any sugaring. The mild sweetness appears to be all natural. This is clearly a sipping rum.

This is an excellent rum and I sincerely hope they get a distribution deal in the United States soon. I understand some liquor stores and bars in south Florida (especially those from the Miami area down to Key West) get bottles of the Watling's rums to bring back by boat. Sadly, I'm in NORTH Florida where the only options are either by cruise ship or by aircraft (neither of which I can afford).

I offer recommendations for not only this rum but also for visiting the Watling distillery (the only distillery in the Bahamas) and taking the tour as well as the tasting offered in their very nice, relaxing bar.

Posted over 3 years ago by Tony from United States with 7 ratings

I enjoyed it because it was not too sweet which I find in most rums. I only wish I could buy this in the US.

Posted about 4 years ago by Chris from United States with 10 ratings

Long time scotch drinker here. Got onto sipping rum when I tasted this during a tour of the Waitling distillery in Nassau.

I had this straight up, not water or ice. Very mild body and very little after burn. Taste was mild coffee and vanilla. Very nice rum.

Can't be bought in the USA.

Posted over 4 years ago by Geno from Canada with 30 ratings

did a walking rum tour in nassau, ending at this distillery. this was their best rum. not bad. drinkable. sippable. not as luxurious a rum as others, then again it was made in a pirate's town. it is worth a try if you are in town. go for a taste, if you like it, buy it.