Thanks so much for submitting a report. It has been emailed to the Rum Captain and will be actioned shortly.
I gave it an 8 rating, but I'd give it a 7.5 if possible. It's tasty, smooth and flavorful. And that aroma,,, I recognize it, but simply can't place it. Quite simply, it does not smell like rum. Some people say "vanilla" and "maple" but I'm thinking it's more complex than that. In any case, I like it very much. I drink my rum straight, no ice. Smoothness is a huge factor for me, and this one is plenty smooth. But it is flavored and that takes away just a bit of desirability in my mind.
Pyrat rum (another flavored rum) is too strongly orange flavored. I won't ever purchase Pyrat again. Papa's Pilar Dark is a far better product, with just a nice hint of complex aroma and flavor. It will have a place in my rum cabinet. I did a direct comparison to Kaniche XO rum, and I still prefer the Kaniche, as the Kaniche is a pure rum, without added flavor.
This rum has a smooth drinkability. It is semi-sweet as a rum should be. The flavor of maple and brown sugar mix well. Wow the more I drink the more I like!
Not to sweet love it.. has a great after taste, with a good strong but smooth flavor
Picked up a bottle of Papas Pilar Dark Rum on my "Bootleggers" trip from Pennsylvania into Maryland and Delaware. Very smooth and tasty rum to sip and I agree with other raters it has a maple taste finish. EDIT: after a few more nights of sipping, I've upped my score to an 8 for Papas. A very good sipping rum.
After much searching, I was finally able to find Papa's Pilar in New Jersey. For me it was worth the wait. I prefer a cork opening instead of the screw top with chain, but that does not detract from the quality of this rum. Mild flavors of maple and vanilla make this a very smooth rum, and the 43% alcohol provides a warming, pleasant burn going down.
Hints of brown sugar and dark molasses. Slight richness & sweetness from the superb mix of several rums. Wonder to sip or on the rocks. Wit would last a little longer if the neck were a little smaller.
Great sipper. Smooth and complex. Hints of coffee and chocolate.
i liked this rum. I got heavy caramel notes. A sweet rum with a cool bottle.
Strong taste of vanilla comes first and sweetness comes later. Good rum for sweet rum lovers.
Very dark sweet rich with molasses flavor and to me a hint if maple. This rum has a place on my top shelf.
Dark color strong caramel scent not as smooth going down as I like but great complex flavors on the palate.
Tried it from all the raving being done. Honestly, not impressed. It wasn't bad, but nothing memorable either. I'll probably give it another chance before I cross it off permanently.
I love everything about this rum. First, the bottle is pure genius. Second, the Hemingway angle is a real winner. Finally, the taste just blows me away. I love sipping on this rum. It is a good thing I can find this pretty easily in New Jersey.