Posting your rating...
Papas Pilar Dark rum

Papas Pilar Dark

United States | Aged

7.7/10 (156 ratings)
Recommendable to most


Rate Papas Pilar Dark

Tap to Rate
Click to Rate

Have an opinion about this rum?

Signup to rate this rum!

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove

156 Papas Pilar Dark ratings

Sort by: Popularity | Date | Rating


Posted 2 months ago by Cowboy Neal from United States with 16 ratings

Very sweet rum, tastes like alcoholic maple syrup. If that's not your thing, avoid this. I personally enjoy sweeter rums though, and this is almost a perfect sipper for me.


Posted 2 months ago by Pipestone from Slovakia with 27 ratings

Because I prefer a sweeter rums I thought I could like it. After testing small issues emerged.
The shape of bottle makes it difficult to pour.
Nose is sweet and little spicy, slightly on Dr.Pepper side.
Taste is similar, sweet and spicy , but there is tiny notes of different flavours which combinations as a whole make me confused.


Posted 4 months ago by Kevin from United States with 31 ratings

Lovely nose. A great sipper at a very reasonable price point. Definitely on my repeat buy list.

Small 310ba019 0ca0 4200 8756 cbdeaeddc8f5

Posted 4 months ago by Jimmy Cliff (PREMIUM) from United States with 232 ratings

I just don’t like the fake sweet tasting maple syrup. There is no way barrel aging can give this sweetness and flavor. Hard to pour without dripping but cool looking bottle. Must be Solara fake aging also.


Posted 4 months ago by pgrace (PREMIUM) from United States with 32 ratings

Nice rum. Great value. Beauty OG bottle paying respect to Mr Hemmingway.

Nose fills with maple Butter. Vanilla sweet dries fruit

Taste lighter than expected. Sugar cane. Vanilla. Sweet spice finish again with the sugar cane


Posted 4 months ago by Swervin_Kervin from United States with 45 ratings

I read the reviews and was expecting to taste a great rum. Papas Pilar just tastes cheap and fake too me. Extra sugar added, thick and syrupy feel on the mouth. Do yourself a favor and buy Zafra instead


Posted 8 months ago by SyreVeeks from United States with 5 ratings

This is a great Rum for a great price. Has a really sweet nose, notes of caramel and brown sugar. Very good sipping rum. Has a nice mouth feel, and finish. Just enough bite to know you're still drinking alcohol.

Small 4u93db6v8yhz

Posted 8 months ago by Anthony C from United States with 125 ratings

This rum is easily found and priced right. This could easily be a 90 dollar bottle. Flavor, sweetness, almost savory. Great warm or from the freezer.


Posted 8 months ago by Willem from Netherlands with 16 ratings

Nice rum, too bad the bottle is empty. Have to go to Florida to get me another bottle


Posted 9 months ago by jeffjp from United States with 6 ratings

Tried this rum in Key West and I can say that the version they serve is better than what you get at your liquor store. The regular market Pilar is produced for them in Jamaica I think, and is not nearly as good as the small batch you can get in KW.