Posting your rating...
Papas Pilar Dark rum

Papas Pilar Dark

United States | Aged

7.7/10(159 ratings)
Recommendable to most


Rate Papas Pilar Dark

Tap to Rate
Click to Rate

Have an opinion about this rum?

Signup to rate this rum!

Advert Image

Advertisement | Go Premium to remove

159 Papas Pilar Dark ratings

Sort by: Popularity | Date | Rating


Posted over 4 years ago by Rob from United States with 50 ratings

It remind me of Zapaca 23 with a shorter finish and less balance. You get a little extra spice for the sherry aging. Good, but a little to sweet for drinking neat. It makes the best rum and coke I have had but its priced out of the mixing category.


Posted over 4 years ago by Mike Gregory from United States with 9 ratings

Very well tasting, price is great and the overall quality of this rum is superb.


Posted over 4 years ago by Wolfsgeist from United States with 6 ratings

I am relatively new to Rums. At first taste it was really dark and strong. After the first glass (straight no ice) I really came to appreciate how complex and warm this Rum is. Its sweet and has a vanilla after taste that isn't strong, its just there. I can't stand rums that taste like syrup and I don't feel that this does. When I mix this with Coke I don't feel like this overpowers or kills the overall taste. This is a solid Rum, great straight, or with Coke. I have done a couple of mixed drinks with it and LOVE the flavor that this brings to the drink.


Posted over 4 years ago by jmp3 from United States with 88 ratings

Very sweet rum or is it a rhum, very easy drinking with very little alcohol bite. First impression was that it was a spiced rum but it is not supposed to be. Great rum if you want something sweet and easy drinking straight.


Posted almost 5 years ago by Dale from United States with 13 ratings

Beautiful color, sweet and vanilla. The blending and aging process are a little suspect to me, but it's definitely worth a try.


Posted almost 5 years ago by Chet from United States with 193 ratings

This is an Excellent Rum. From the moment you open it up you will notice that wonderful butterscotch, vanilla and caramel fragrance. The finish is one that lasts like a welfare recipient reaching for another check. Very well worth the money and I will always have this fine product in my cabinet.


Posted 5 years ago by Ramon from United States with 76 ratings

Great Motto, and some great tasting Rum ! Sure it's sweet and maple flavored but straight up or on the rocks it never starts tasting bad or overbearing. Smoooooth all the way. Modeled after the real most interesting man in the world this is good stuff, the story and the packaging are outstanding. Even without a box would make a great gift. I wonder if it would fit in a real canteen belt holster ? This is going to look great on my bottle wall, I just wish the compass on the top was real. Watching the Super Bowl, but I'm not a spectator !


Posted 5 years ago by John Lopez from United States with 1 rating

Very spicy and smoky very aromatic
Fine brandylike


Posted 5 years ago by 2.ooohhh from United States with 42 ratings

Caramel, Vanilla, Molasses, Rasin, and oaky port. All swirled in a glass with this one.


Posted 5 years ago by steve rector from United States with 11 ratings

Maybe I expected more as it was built up pretty high... Not a bad rum and I may have a different opinion of it 6 mos from now... Lots of vanilla which I am a fan of if im mixing. I dont spend this kind of money on mixers, gotta be a sipper at this price and I'm not sure at this point that its is...