Posting your rating...
Siesta Key Spiced rum

Siesta Key Spiced rum, a version of their Silver Rum that’s infused with natural spices and added honey for sweetness and flavor. Bottled at 70 proof.

via American Rum Report

Rate Siesta Key Spiced

Tap to Rate
Click to Rate

Have an opinion about this rum?

Signup to rate this rum!


28 Siesta Key Spiced ratings

Sort by: Popularity | Date | Rating

Posted over 5 years ago by DelectaBlee from United States with 59 ratings

While I'm not a big fan of spiced rums, this one is the best I've tried. It's made with all natural spices, not as sweet as other spiced rums and the flavor reminded me a little of ginger bread. I've rated this among all the rums I've tried but if I were to rate spiced rums on their own, I'd give this a solid 10. My friend who shared it with me said he made egg nog with it that turned out great.

Posted over 2 years ago by Handsome Alex (PREMIUM) from United States with 87 ratings

... and I've done a lot of "research". For that guy who started on Captain Morgan in college, then grew to enjoy some of the finer things in life, this is a great way to go back to my roots. A local rum made in Florida that is hands-down my favorite spiced rum. For those critical of the sweeter rums, this one isn't for you. They don't hide the fact that they add honey with the spices before aging, but the final result is worth it. You can pick out the honey, clove, and nutmeg, and at 70% abv, it's pretty smooth. Use in anything you would have used the Cap'n to kick it up a notch. I like it with Coke and lime.

Posted over 2 years ago by Scott T from United States with 120 ratings

Superbly drinkable, like a gingerbread cookie in a glass. One of the best spiced rums I have had. You don't even have to drink it, just smell it.

Posted about 3 years ago by mistercoughy from United States with 239 ratings

Wow. It's not often that you find a spiced rum that hasn't been sugared beyond reason. This one is definitely not too sweet. That's the good news.

The less-good news is that it has more nutmeg than a spice hut in the Banda Islands. In other words, too much. Nevertheless, it has garnered some great reviews here. Maybe it's me. Actually, with all the extra nutmeg, this rum might shine in a Painkiller. Definitely worth a try.

Posted almost 4 years ago by nomad from United States with 125 ratings

All of the fall spices are present, with cinnamon and nutmeg up front. Eggnog and coffee based drinks should work well, probably works well in food recipes too.

Posted over 4 years ago by Falcon91Wolvrn03 (PREMIUM) from United States with 424 ratings

Smelling this instantly reminded me of pumpkin pie! It's actually ok for a flavored rum, and I think pumpkin pie goes a lot better with rum than some of the other flavors I've tried (grape, lemon, etc). Still, I'm not as big a fan of the flavored rums as I am the traditional aged rums.

Smells and tastes of pumpkin pie, with nutmeg, cinnamon, brown sugar, and vanilla, this is definitely a decent rum. But I'm rating it against all rums, not just flavored rums (this is currently categorized as a 'spiced rum', but I believe it should be a 'flavored rum', though that doesn't effect my rating.)

Posted over 4 years ago by Beukeboom from United States with 305 ratings

Kind of ironic that I try this spiced rum less than a week before Thanksgiving. It definitely smells and tastes of pumpkin spice (nice nutmeg). Very smooth rum with good after-warmth. Never a harsh burn. Thanksgiving is the perfect time to use this as a sipping rum and in Thanksgiving-themed mixers. Pumpkin punch anyone? Doesn't work as well in colas IMHO but does make for a unique combination. Siesta Key rum is made in small batches at a family-run distillery in Sarasota, Florida which happens to be about 12 miles from Siesta Key, Florida (initially I erroneously thought Siesta Key was somewhere between Miami and Key West). This rum has won awards and I understand why. Very good stuff.

Posted almost 5 years ago by Dave from United States with 36 ratings

good mixed with coke although does have a strong honey and spice aftertaste.

Posted almost 6 years ago by lmolinajr from United States with 17 ratings

If there's a rum to have in your collection,this is one of them.made in copper pot still.You can really taste the molasses made from florida sugarcane.Excellent for sipping or with cola.They now offer tours of the distillary.

Posted 9 months ago by jamesshaffer (PREMIUM) from United States with 24 ratings

I'm not much of a rum sipper. However, I often take a taste from a new bottle...just to see what I'm about to experience. I have to say that this is the best tasting rum I've tried in some time! If you drink rum straight, you should give this one a try. For me...As always, I enjoy my rum over ice with a healthy splash of Coke.

Post-review edit. In spite of the nutmeg flavor punching you in the taste buds, this spiced rum just goes down so easily. For me, it gets better and better with every drink. This would easily be a solid 10 for me...if they could tone down the nutmeg just a tad. This will for sure be the star in some eggnog at Christmas!

Posted 12 months ago by Derek from United States with 13 ratings

This was a fantastic treat and break from the “basic” spiced rum everyone got.

Posted about 1 year ago by Schnatterer from Switzerland with 20 ratings

This is a nice spiced rum. The flavours are balanced in mouth...

Posted about 1 year ago by ColoRobO from United States with 4 ratings

This was not my thing. Nutmeg and allspice is dominant. Otherwise it’s not bad, but unless I’m spiking egg nog or pumpin pie milk shakes, this isn’t a spiced rum I would keep around for cola or fruit juice mixer.

Posted over 1 year ago by Michael N from United States with 69 ratings

I’m not much for spiced rum. A friend of mine brought a bottle of this back for me as a gift. It is very different from the usual Captain Morgan’s or other standard selling spiced rums. Very subtle and tasty, not sweet or harsh. Now I’d like to try other offerings from Siesta Key!

Posted over 1 year ago by Wayne from United States with 2 ratings

This is the only spiced rum I drink. As a sipping rum, it has just the right amount of spice.

If you want an interesting tropical flavor, try a 50-50 mix with Siesta Key Toasted Coconut Rum.

This is also a great rum to use when making Coquito (Puerto Rican no-egg eggnog).

Posted over 1 year ago by Shyanha from United States with 6 ratings

Confession: Captain Morgan's Spiced was the only spiced rum I'd had before this. The difference is noticeable. I stopped drinking the Captain's Spiced because regular rum tastes better to me.

With that in mind, when I first tasted Siesta Key Spiced I was surprised. I could taste actual spices. Cinnamon and clove is mostly what I taste, though now that I know honey is used I can detect that as well. I couldn't quite put my finger on that flavor.

I prefer to mix my liquor so I can make drinks last (I'm not good at sipping). So far it's gone well with Sprite, Ginger Ale, Ginger Ale with a squirt of Grenadine (not Great, but not bad, either), Cranberry Cocktail, CranApple, and mulled apple cider (sinuses and sore throat get put in check with apple cider mulled with cinnamon, cloves, and allspice). I saw someone tried it with Diet A&W Root Beer - I don't think I am that brave! I'd skip Coca Cola as well. If there is a pumpkin drink somewhere this would pair nicely.

Over ice or in a heated drink I'm almost always up for a sit down with this guy.

Posted over 1 year ago by Joola69 from United States with 2555 ratings

Had a rum tasting on a sunny afternoon, because why not. Siesta Key Spiced bottle and label design looks like homemade. Light golden color. Super strong nutmeg to the nose and palate. Too much is too much. No burn at all most likely from the honey being used to sweeten it up.

Posted over 2 years ago by Paul B (PREMIUM) from United States with 297 ratings

This rum has the most pronounced nutmeg flavor that I have ever tried. However, knowing what I know about the aftermath effects of nutmeg, I would not even think of drinking too much of this. A common practice on Caribbean party boats is to add lots of nutmeg to high proof rum punch. Everyone is very happy at the end of the trip and the tips flow more easily into the buckets with the tour guides grinning from ear to ear. And the next day, all of those party animals are all sick as can be with king hell headaches.

This is indeed one very tasty and unique spiced rum. Just be careful on over doing it. It can be sipped neat, on the rocks, or in very exotic tropical drinks that do not include sodas.

Update a few days later: Both the positive and negative effects of the nutmeg have been obliterated by whatever secret this distiller knows. I doubt that honey is the secret, but it certainly takes away from the tropical flavors, so I now dock it one point.

Posted over 2 years ago by Cejer from United States with 9 ratings

Smooth and sweet with honey. A touch of cinnamon and nutmeg, but easy to drink neat. Soft sweet finish, enjoyable in the mouth. It got a bit cloying on my second glass, but if you like honey, then this is quite tasty.

Posted over 2 years ago by M from United States with 30 ratings

Tasty spiced rum from Florida. Very good choice especially for low $$ . Strong pumpkin spices along with cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice. Finished with some vanilla and honey. Sweet but not overly sweet and still maintains a natural taste unlike some spiced rums. I still prefer Brinley Shipwreck Gold but this is most definitely worth keeping on hand .

In the Mouth 50/60

Posted over 2 years ago by Casey Gotcher from United States with 7 ratings

Nice spiced rum. Good flavor. Didn’t enjoy as a sipping rum, but really liked with some A&W Diet Root Beer.

Posted over 2 years ago by Joshua from United States with 29 ratings

This was pretty good stuff. It's easy on the nose and tastes great. Not much burn very smooth and can be enjoyed neat or mixed. Picked this up while visiting Siesta Key and really enjoy having this in my collection.

Posted almost 3 years ago by "Samuel Brunello" from United States with 78 ratings

Spiced rums are supposed to be dark and brooding, with an excessively vast spice bouquet that works together with a high proof to beat your tastebuds into submission! They're dominated by vanilla, added molasses and most improtantly: alcohol!
Meanwhile you've got this little pansey over here, sitting at 35% and boasting no components any fiercer than a cinnamon graham cracker. It feels watery, and carries a dainty sweetness from added honey. It feels watery, with some spices doing a nice little ballet in your mouth, which then gather around the (tiny) fire to discuss their feelings...
As if this wasn't made clear, this is a super pleasant rumOH GOSH NO I mean this rum is weak, and light, and is perfect for adding a spice kick to your drinksDANG IT! It can't even ramp up your cocktails ABV while adding some depthGAHH! Ok, the jig is up... This is far and away the most friendly and tasty of the spiced rums I've had! This stuff is a steal at only $25, and it is so darn drinkable!

Posted almost 3 years ago by Travis from United States with 8 ratings

For something that is local to the Sarasota area it is really good