Thanks so much for submitting a report. It has been emailed to the Rum Captain and will be actioned shortly.
While exploring the Abyss of rum, I found this one to be one of the darkest of all. It does have a sweet vanilla cherry smell to it but not overpowering at all. This one didn't jump out at me one way or the other, the flavour seemed almost perfectly neutral, not sweet, not citrus, and even the alcohol doesn't burn. But beware it is lurking in the briny deep and will strike without warning. This rum is smooth and I could drink one after another on the rocks and not tire of the flavour. May end up smashed on the rocks :-)
This rum I was not expecting much from. In fact I thought I would hate it. This is a rum I was aware of for a while. I stopped by a liquor store I never frequent after picking up some dry cleaning. I never like to leave some place without buying anything. This place made it really hard I either have and had not tried everything they had or had, or would never buy or drink it (swill). I saw this bottle and I did consider this to be on my trying list, given its history as a blend created in Hawaii. At 14.99 for 1L I decided to try it, I was in a rare mood for some Cuba Libre. I opened this bottle and I can't say I hated the Aroma of it. In fact I somewhat mildly enjoyed the aroma of this bottle at that price point I heavily enjoyed it actually. The smell almost was of bubblegum and I found my self sniffing the bottle at one point. I tried this against all advice neat first. It had some light fire in the throat but overall I was surprised and consider this a rum that could be sipped rather easily. I mixed this with coke and lime, it was excellent no complaints. This was a surprise to me. I can't rate this less than a 7 due to the price point.
Enjoyed a glass of Whaler's Original Dark Rum with my friend while road tripping through 18 states and 5,000 miles. Nice and unique bottle design but very dull and cheap looking label. Deep brown color, almost blackish. Plenty of weird and very offputting artificial flavors to the nose and palate mixed with some wood and oak. Some burn at the end, but the finish is just simply too sweet.
I first tried this rum in Hawaii way back in 1994. My memory of it was awful, so I have ignored it every time I see it on the shelves. Well after a long drive to pick up 8 new rums and then checking into my lodging for party central, I decided to walk across the street to pick up a six pack of beer. Since this store is noted for it's decent selection of rums (albeit expensive), I decided to check that part out. There were all of the Whaler rums on the bottom shelf, with this one only being $15. So I thought WTF and brought it back to my room. I did at least wait until I got back home to try it because this stuff does not mix in my stomach with beer. I also hate Dark & Stormys, which this one would theoretically do well in.
All I can say now is that it is slightly smoother than Myer's Dark. I gather that casks of this Hawaiian rum are now shipped to the bourbon capital of the world in Bardstown, Kentucky, which is where this is now bottled. I no longer find it disgusting, but I have had many more rums that taste a lot worse than this one. This will do well in coffee, and basically, that is all this rum is good for.
Bottle shape a bit different but otherwise identical appearance to one on this site. One liter $10 at Trader Joes, $12 at Bevmo. While sweetness is probably influencing my opinion, its a great QPR (quality to price ratio)
Wow I was expecting a deep dark rum and at sight it is nearly black but nose was very artificial vanilla and strong . The mouth was a bit sweet as well as the finish . I tried it neat and my conclusion was I had better mix it . As a mixer I found it just okay but not that bad. I would use this Rum as a party Rum as long as there is plenty of Coca Cola to subdue it’s artificial flavor. The bottle is classic but that is where I stop recommending this spirit. All in all it is passable.If it’s a sweet , earthy rum you want then you found it
I love the sweet yet musky burn to it!!!! The sweet flavor is almost like a molasses taste.
Decent dark rum, kinda falls short on the finish. Good with a splash of coke though..
Unlike someone else, I didn't detect a noticeable sweet fragrance from the bottle but more a subtle sweet odor. It does have a sweet flavor to it with an unexpected complexity to it. This could make for a nice sipping rum if you like the sweet ones. IMHO one of the better dark rums for mixing. Works well in Coke Zero. [NOTE: Used 3oz in a 16.9oz Coke Zero mixed together in a cup and it is outstanding!]
Very sweet smell coming from this one right out the cork. Of fruit and maybe some toffee. No real alcohol smell. In the glass it smells like straight alcohol. Drinking it straight isnt a bad idea. Has a little bite up front. But the smell of alcohol chokes you so I wouldn't recommend. In coke it tastes like the smell of the bottle. Has a nice fruity entry with some sweetness then a bitter after taste that I dont like. So I dont really care for this rum. HOWEVER if you like Kraken this is just as good and a little cheaper. In reality its very similar to kraken with more sweetness.
I was sure about this one but I was in Hawiai so I tried a bottle. I was pleasantly suprised.
Nowadays I find Whalers at Trader Joes for a good price. Nice dark body, decent flavor for sipping straight or mixing.
My other experience with rum this darkbis Gosling's, I would pick which ever is cheaper at the time. Both are nice.
Another nice dark rum for mixing
Your average dark rum for the bar. Not the best, not the worst. It's fine for drinks that require ginger beer.
This is another rum I use with ginger beer. It's dark and smooth enough to offset the light and crispy taste of the ginger beer and create the perfect afternoon delight!